I think it's worthless.. I know I'm not the one who makes decisions etc, and this is not directed towards the Op etc.. but in my opinion the more you add to a forum in the way of making it "automatic" or to try and build some users ego the more distant users become..
The system here works pretty good, you get a personal note from the good mods here..or the bad mods however you look at it that's your on personal view.. As to stats etc when you put someone up on a pedestal the only good thing to do is remove that pedestal !! as well no one wants to be in a forum where few run the post, and theirs is the only opinion worthwhile...
A forum is a touchy thing, it can be the biggest greatest, and a little change can bring the walls tumbling down.. to NOTHING, and WORTHLESS