Book says about the Death of Expertise. About how we looking for simplistic answers for everything. "Captain" Joe is part of that problem. 1. He is using his uniform to give opinion. He does not have facts at his disposal. 2. He is misrepresenting himself. His rank (real one), uniform, carries weight. When I go out to talk using my title, I always make sure I have all the facts at disposal as 1. My credibility is at stake, 2. my institutions credibility is at stake.
But, bigger problem is that we are creating environment where we want simple answers, quickly, for extremely complex issues.
One student (graduate) asked me few months back: why DoD has such a large budget? And can you explain me like I am in kindergarten? That right there is a problem. I told her to change career.
Get a book, a lot to unpack there, and I am giving you simple explanation, which I just ranted against