The first filter must have been changed at some point, because the ones with a plastic frame and rubber gasket are aftermarket. The one-piece in your fourth photo is the OEM design.
When I had a '10 Vibe, I found out that AC Delco A3103C is a reboxed Toyota-Denso filter. I got a couple of those with rebates last year for an '18 Corolla.
I once ordered the Denso "First Time Fit" model from RockAuto. It was the OEM design, but there was a molding defect at one corner that made me think it wouldn't seal properly.