I have used both on my Toyota pickup, and both seem to do fine.
I was buying the YZZD1 from my local Toyota dealer, and then all of a sudden they would not sell it to me because the part number was superseded to 90915-YZZG2. The YZZG2 is made by Purolator. The dealer wanted more money too, so I started buying the 910S for about $4 from the local Walmart.
Anyway, I have cut open both the D1 and 910S. The D1 is basically a cartridge filter in a can. It's a good quality filter. The 910S has always looked good too, but I do think the D1 is better made with the cartridge filter in a can.