You really need to watch the videos so you can gain some insight. The defender 2, very good tire overall BUT was lacking some in wet weather traction and rode stiffer than much of the competition. I forget what noise was.
The tires on my Accord are discontinued, Pirelli P7 AS+2, I bought for the noise, handling, wear. They have lived up to that. Totally different than than the previous Goodyear WeatherReady which were some of loudest tires I ever had.
You asked for 3 choices. We are trying to help you with comparable options and most likely price point. If you are stuck on just those 3, number each one 1-3 and do a random number generator or toss a dart at the names. Each one of those has positives and negatives and different categories so your particular priority is what matters. I'll give up some life for good wet and dry grip with very low noise and comfortable ride for my highway cruises but those are my priorities. I also run full winter set so snow traction on my 3 season I could care less.
Choice 4 since you commented on first post. Sentury Touring all-season (ideal for commute). If you are happy with them why change?