I never have had enough loyalty to a single station to consider an oil-major branded card (plus, we are mostly Casey's/HyVee/QT/Kwik Shop/Maverik (former Kum and Go)) in this part of the world, minus the occasional BP/Amoco or Phillips 66. Fuel-ups on road trips are whatever I find convenient, but those are likely regional chains or Loves/Pilot etc. Oil-major branded stations aren't nearly as common here as other parts of the country.
So I just use my regular USBank Visa at the pump, and don't worry about skimming (it's not happened to me in the 11 years I've been pumping gas, 300k plus miles worth, and I trust them to sort it out if need be given it's "their money"). That said, I do use tap-to-pay when available. My debit card stays locked and is unlocked via the app just for a fee-free ATM once a quarter or so.