Reply from Mobil 1 concerning basestocks

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote:


Its the other oil companies, not the consumers, that Mobil wants to keep their recipe from.




If Tom can find out what M1 uses with G.C., there is no doubt in my mind that any petroleum engineering staff could find out the same thing. This is a matter of profit over principle. In the long run BITOG members will feel better about using an alternative product, but Mobil wont be affected 1/2 of 1%. Blind faith from the majority of the herd will win every time. Now, please excuse me, my neighbor wants an M1/Fram change in her Saturn.
 
Think Mobil 1 is over priced? Don't buy it. Think the Sopus or other oils are better or better values? Buy them.

Some of you are acting like your wife cheated on you. It's just motor oil..and I bet still a very good oil at that.

The extra .75-1.00 a qt make you feel like you are getting ripped off...then as I stated above, buy something else.
 
I will now buy Amsoil. I now use there ATF, Gear oil and grease. All worked great. I though that is was easy to buy
M1, but how much easer can it get to have it delivered to your door. ________ Al,s and old fighter jockey.
 
Hi gang, I sent Mobil another e-mail stating that even though they use some PAO that it may be possible that they have switched to a group 3 basestock as their main ingredient. Let's see if that gets them riled up.
 
KJ, you should have also sent them this:
Quote:


Semi-Synthetics

Semi-Synthetics use base stocks comprising conventional or hydroprocessed base oil in combination with severely hydroprocessed or synthetic (PAO) basestocks. The proportion of severely hydroprocessed or synthetic basestocks in semi-synthetic oil is a closely guarded secret, but is usually between 10% and 25%.




...oh btw, this is from XOM's Australian website. So I guess Mobil 1 should be changed to semi-synthetic by their own definition.
 
Quote:


KJ, you should have also sent them this:
Quote:


Semi-Synthetics

Semi-Synthetics use base stocks comprising conventional or hydroprocessed base oil in combination with severely hydroprocessed or synthetic (PAO) basestocks. The proportion of severely hydroprocessed or synthetic basestocks in semi-synthetic oil is a closely guarded secret, but is usually between 10% and 25%.




...oh btw, this is from XOM's Australian website. So I guess Mobil 1 should be changed to semi-synthetic by their own definition.




I read that link too and it is pretty good reading. Also, I'm completely with you on that statement. It seems we may be getting somewhere with all of this.
patriot.gif
 
So far, no reply from Mobil. They may just dodge my question altogether. I'm losing my trust in them and very well may look to other oils in the future.
 
I don't see where is the problem. They say that in a semisynthetic the base oil is conventional or hydroprocessed combined with 10-25% synthetic which can be severely hydroprocessed or PAO.
 
What I want to know is if the latest M1 offerings still resist heat up to 400F, like they claimed in 2004? My '97 Camry sludger needs an oil that can withstand high-temp!
 
Quote:


I don't see where is the problem. They say that in a semisynthetic the base oil is conventional or hydroprocessed combined with 10-25% synthetic which can be severely hydroprocessed or PAO.




I was wondering when someone was going to notice that and post about it.
thumbsup.gif
 
Quote:


OMG. All this babbling, one BITOG expert later, and everyone is dumping M1?
You gotta be kidding me?




Nope. People feel shafted. They expected the best of the best and Mobil1 has (thanks to its marketing) given them the impression the best of the best doesn't include group III.

And that one BITOG expert is certainly in a position to know what he's talking about.
 
Around the ExxonMobil customer service water cooler...

"So how many questions about whether Mobil 1 is really synthetic today, Jim?"

"About 87,000. Pretty average. Maybe up a bit."

"Yeah, me too. I've been getting some emails from some weirdos though. Say they belong to some group called GOBIT or OBTIG or something."

"Same here. Keep saying Mobil 1 is fake 'cause of some GC test."

"What's German Castrol got to do with us?"

"Beats me. Did you give them the 'Mobil 1 continues to be made from 100% synthetic basestock' one?"

"Of course. But they kept rambling about group III not being true synthetic. Not that we use group III!" (looks around fearfully in case a boss is nearby)

"I know the feeling. I pulled out the 'we use PAO technology in all our oils' line and they still won't go away. One of them even said he'd dug up some big rock and was gonna drop it on my car! Must be some kinda cult."

"Yeah, this job ain't worth it anymore. Used to just be answering stuff like 'How many horsepower will I gain by switching to Mobil 1?' Now I get guys threatening to send me pictures of David Hasselhoff. I'm gonna go ask for a raise."
 
Quote:


I don't see where is the problem. They say that in a semisynthetic the base oil is conventional or hydroprocessed combined with 10-25% synthetic which can be severely hydroprocessed or PAO.




Have you seen some of their comments to our questions or their adverts? Implies 100% synth PAO...that's the prob.
 
I think i got not now, you are referring to the 10-25% of the package. They distinguish it as severely hydroprocessed or synthetic basestocks implying that only PAO is synthetic basestock. On the other hand they recognise by definition that a combination between conventional and severely hydroprocessed(group III) can still be called semisynthetic.
That's really confusing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom