Radar Detectors - Recommendations, Please.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: MCompact


The FCC does not regulate laser devices- the FDA is the agency that deals with laser transmitting and exposure. Some states prohibit laser jammers but there's no federal legislation or regulation that prohibits their manufacture and/or use.


Good to know. Thanks. I guess I was leaning on lasers being in the electromagnetic spectrum just like RF. My bad. I sure would hate to try and explain that to a State Trooper. Lordy.
 
Well I've been running the Uniden R3 for almost a week now and it is the most sensitive detector I have ever used. It totally knocks my Valentine 1 out of the water. The trouble is, it is too sensitive. It is constantly going off on k band. I have the k band filters on, city mode on and tried narrow and wide k settings, but it picks every new GM, Honda, Acura and other vehicles with the blind spot mirrors blocks away. Not to mention k band door openers. I am used to quiet, this thing is not. Uniden is listening to those rdforum enthusiasts that only care about the longest range. I bought it from Bestradardetectors.net and they allow returns but since I got free shipping I have to pay for the shipping to me and take a 15% restocking fee, plus the cost of shipping it back. If you don't mind it going off every 2 blocks it's ok. Really long range, but that is the problem it picks up everything. I get Walgreen's from 1/4 mile away now. I used to have to be right in front of it. If you do want one wait until Amazon has them in case you want to return it. I am stuck with it for now. Don't buy from bestradardetectors.net if having a return option is important to you.
 
I drive roughly 30,000 miles annually throughout the east coast, south, and midwest both for work and leisure. Doing so in the past I have averaged 2 speeding tickets per year and they were blatant speed traps not over zealous speeding. Since I prefer not to be victimized I almost always drive with a radar detector nowadays.


So far I am pleased with the performance of the Escort 360 max and my average in speeding tickets has dropped to zero this past year so I can't complain.

k0k5jo.jpg
 
Originally Posted By: HosteenJorje
Drive the posted speed limit and you won't need one.
smile.gif



The op did not ask whether or not he should he should get one.
 
Originally Posted By: HosteenJorje
Drive the posted speed limit and you won't need one.
smile.gif


How do you handle in your perfect world, the locations where the speed changes in 20 ft (45 than 30), or the speed sign is hidden by tree leaves?
it smell to me like a speed trap....
 
Nothing is going to help when you get the airplane speeding ticket. Those white lines on the road are there for a reason. speed=distance/time
 
Originally Posted By: BigD1
Nothing is going to help when you get the airplane speeding ticket. Those white lines on the road are there for a reason. speed=distance/time



Does anyone do that anymore?

Aviation departments of State Police agencies have been gutted. I've not seen those white lines in a while....
 
Originally Posted By: sprite1741
Well I've been running the Uniden R3 for almost a week now and it is the most sensitive detector I have ever used. It totally knocks my Valentine 1 out of the water. The trouble is, it is too sensitive. It is constantly going off on k band. I have the k band filters on, city mode on and tried narrow and wide k settings, but it picks every new GM, Honda, Acura and other vehicles with the blind spot mirrors blocks away. Not to mention k band door openers. I am used to quiet, this thing is not. Uniden is listening to those rdforum enthusiasts that only care about the longest range. I bought it from Bestradardetectors.net and they allow returns but since I got free shipping I have to pay for the shipping to me and take a 15% restocking fee, plus the cost of shipping it back. If you don't mind it going off every 2 blocks it's ok. Really long range, but that is the problem it picks up everything. I get Walgreen's from 1/4 mile away now. I used to have to be right in front of it. If you do want one wait until Amazon has them in case you want to return it. I am stuck with it for now. Don't buy from bestradardetectors.net if having a return option is important to you.


I know that thing has GPS. Does it not have automatic lockouts for the stationary K-band false threats? Also, from what I've read, Uniden does a good job with filtering for the vehicle anti-collision radars. But there are some (like the late-model GM & Honda corporate vehicles) that almost no detectors can filter out because they're almost the same frequency as legit police speed radars. If you lock the filters down too tight then yeah, it's quiet, but is it going to alert to a legit threat? So it's a balancing act.

Does it have a signal strength meter? If so, that is a really helpful tool in separating out the falses.
 
As a former traffic enforcement officer I used to write tickets everyday to people who had RADAR detectors. This was 10+ yeas ago. I never wrote anyone for less than 20 over the limit.
 
Originally Posted By: Astro14
Originally Posted By: BigD1
Nothing is going to help when you get the airplane speeding ticket. Those white lines on the road are there for a reason. speed=distance/time



Does anyone do that anymore?

Aviation departments of State Police agencies have been gutted. I've not seen those white lines in a while....


Can't say they do now in any particular area because I don't drive all over the country like I used to do when I was driving over the road. I still see the lines occasionally on my limited travels. Back when I was driving OTR, I saw more birds in the air doing business in Ohio than any other state, and California and Florida were not far behind.

In Florida at the Bay bridge, they would use a helicopter to clock speed coming across the bridge, and at the end of the bridge there would be an army of cops on motorcycles lined up to write tickets. Not sure how the helicopter was getting the speed.

Here is information from a law office about aircraft speeding tickets in Florida, so I reckon they are still doing it in Florida sparingly.

http://fightyourspeedingticket.com/types-speed-measurement-devices/aircraft-speeding-tickets/
 
Originally Posted By: john_pifer

I know that thing has GPS. Does it not have automatic lockouts for the stationary K-band false threats? Also, from what I've read, Uniden does a good job with filtering for the vehicle anti-collision radars. But there are some (like the late-model GM & Honda corporate vehicles) that almost no detectors can filter out because they're almost the same frequency as legit police speed radars. If you lock the filters down too tight then yeah, it's quiet, but is it going to alert to a legit threat? So it's a balancing act.

Does it have a signal strength meter? If so, that is a really helpful tool in separating out the falses.


The R3 has GPS,and signal meter but no auto lockout. The R3 K filter is not as good as the V1. Yesterday I got stuck behind a GM suv that falsed from a 1/4 mile. Today a VW Passat at 24.244. I have it k narrow and it should not have picked up the VW. It happens many times a day. I just have to hit the mute or shut the thing off. If the next firmware wont fix it, I am done with Uniden, they are listening to the hard core speeders on the rdforum who want nothing but long range and don't care if it never shuts up. I just want to be alerted to watch my speed. The R3 is useless to the casual driver that just wants a decent radar detector to stay alert to conditions.
 
Originally Posted By: GenSan
I drive roughly 30,000 miles annually throughout the east coast, south, and midwest both for work and leisure. Doing so in the past I have averaged 2 speeding tickets per year and they were blatant speed traps not over zealous speeding. Since I prefer not to be victimized I almost always drive with a radar detector nowadays.


So far I am pleased with the performance of the Escort 360 max and my average in speeding tickets has dropped to zero this past year so I can't complain.

k0k5jo.jpg



I went with a Max 360 as well. I've used it for a few weeks now, including on a 7-hour drive to the Gulf Coast and back. I think it's a very good (possibly the best) all-around radar detector. It was expensive ($650) but it has lots of features. I really like how it automatically locks out stationary false K-band signals from door openers, etc. I also love the arrows. This being my first radar detector, I think I'd feel pretty blind without the arrows. The arrows helps in a lot of situations, especially when I pass a cop on the highway going the opposite direction but never see him. Without the arrows pointing first forward, then briefly to the side, then behind me, I wouldn't know if it was a hint of a signal from a cop shooting radar somewhere down the road. With the arrows, it lets me know that the threat has passed.

K-band falsing from vehicle anti-collision systems does happen but mostly from GM & Honda, the worst offenders. And with the benefit of the signal strength meter, you can usually differentiate a false from a legit threat (not even sure if they use K in Tennessee; I know that the large urban areas as well as THP are almost exclusively Ka-band). I have yet to run into a cop running K.

From what I've read, the Valentine is probably a little better at K filtering but you have to run the phone app alongside it to have the features of the Max 360, and I don't want to have to do that. Comparing range, the two are comparable in most situations with the Max 360 coming out on top in some situations and the Valentine winning others.

With the Escort Live! app that reports live police radar in your area via your phone (you can run the app in the background), the Defender database that reports red light and speed cams and known speed traps, and running Waze, you have a pretty powerful set of countermeasures.
 
Originally Posted By: Astro14
Originally Posted By: BigD1
Nothing is going to help when you get the airplane speeding ticket. Those white lines on the road are there for a reason. speed=distance/time



Does anyone do that anymore?

Aviation departments of State Police agencies have been gutted. I've not seen those white lines in a while....


I've certainly never seen it in Tennessee. I've seen signs warning of air enforcement but never actually heard of it happening. Like others have said, I've heard of it more in places like Florida. Honestly there's not all that much speed enforcement in Memphis and Nashville. Frankly, in our urban areas, there's a lot of real crime to keep the police busy.
 
Originally Posted By: Buzzsaw
As a former traffic enforcement officer I used to write tickets everyday to people who had RADAR detectors. This was 10+ yeas ago. I never wrote anyone for less than 20 over the limit.



A lot of people just buy a radar detector and think it gives them a license to speed. Those are the people you probably were catching. You have to be smart about it. A detector is only one tool in your arsenal of anti-velocity tax countermeasures.
 
V1 and Waze a very powerful combo.

Only waze will alert you to a guy with binoculars miles away using timing marks.

That said I rarely sustain more than 15 over maybe a burst or two to get around two trucks or something like that, and only on multilane freeways in between cities. I use the detector here so as not to get popped when at a passing events.

even without it I routinely pass CHP on the side of the road at 9 over and they dont bat an eye.

In town and inner city freeways its cruise control max 5 over and I go for cheap transit cost speeding in town is tomfoolery and I dont do it.
I dont even bother using a detector in town.

I get my speed kicks on the water where I can enjoy a 700HP 2000LB vehicle at its limits and not be breaking laws.

UD
 
Originally Posted By: Astro14
Originally Posted By: BigD1
Nothing is going to help when you get the airplane speeding ticket. Those white lines on the road are there for a reason. speed=distance/time



Does anyone do that anymore?

Aviation departments of State Police agencies have been gutted. I've not seen those white lines in a while....



Ive seen CHP with binoculars setup on the highway using them vs. airplanes the last 5-10 years.

There are only a few places on the 5 freeway between Los Angeles and Sacramento where the terrain allows it, but I went by a guy with binoculars on tripod a stopwatch and a radio standing in front of an overpass, and there was a second vehicle behind the overpass not using radar just sitting in stealth mode ready to take a radio call.


UD
 
Originally Posted By: UncleDave
Originally Posted By: Astro14
Originally Posted By: BigD1
Nothing is going to help when you get the airplane speeding ticket. Those white lines on the road are there for a reason. speed=distance/time



Does anyone do that anymore?

Aviation departments of State Police agencies have been gutted. I've not seen those white lines in a while....



Ive seen CHP with binoculars setup on the highway using them vs. airplanes the last 5-10 years.

There are only a few places on the 5 freeway between Los Angeles and Sacramento where the terrain allows it, but I went by a guy with binoculars on tripod a stopwatch and a radio standing in front of an overpass, and there was a second vehicle behind the overpass not using radar just sitting in stealth mode ready to take a radio call.


UD


Sure it wasn't LIDAR? Some LIDAR speed detectors look like a pair of binoculars.
 
Perhaps it was.

The road had visible timing marks, and i couldn't say for sure what he had in his the hand, it may not have been a stopwatch.

UD
 
Originally Posted By: UncleDave

Perhaps it was.

The road had visible timing marks, and i couldn't say for sure what he had in his the hand, it may not have been a stopwatch.

UD


Check this out. It's one of the more common LIDAR speed-checking units that the cops use:

http://kustomsignals.com/products/product/pro_lite

Small enough for a motorcycle cop to easily carry with him.
 
Originally Posted By: Buzzsaw
As a former traffic enforcement officer I used to write tickets everyday to people who had RADAR detectors. This was 10+ yeas ago. I never wrote anyone for less than 20 over the limit.

Did the presence or absence of a radar detector play a deciding factor in whether or not the speeder was issued a citation?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom