- That trick of removing a glue joint is new to me. Does it work on old construction that has a good glue joint?? It would be foolish to do this on a pressure joint, IMO, because I would fear the quality of the reglued joint. None the less, a neat method to put into my bag-o-tricks.
- Since this is a non pressure condensate drain, I would personally work from the easiest to hardest solution. This joint is non critical and won't result in a flood.
First, I understand where Plumber is coming from. One fix, no call back. With his tools, materials, and experience, he could replace the whole assembly in 45 minutes, and likely charge the homeowner about $200-$300. Based on the OP, he likely would require help to DIY this. The 4 inch (?) pipe would have to be cut back 10" on each side of this joint assembly and then be rebuilt.
- Where does the 3/4" condensate drain go to? I would check to make sure it is not blocked, resulting in water backing up over the poor joint. This might solve your problem right off. Not a real fix, but the problem leak might go away.
- Any glue/epoxy/caulk repair will require to clean AND dry the joint totally.
- I would clean the entire circumference of the bad joint thoroughly, then clean it again. Then, MAYBE, just applying PVC cleaner (clear - less unsightly) around the joint will stop the leak by it by wicking up into, and expanding/melting the tiny leak. Maybe. You will need finesse and some thin brushes to work neatly on this "upside down" repair.
- If that doesn't work, you could try 3 "glue" choices. Clean the joint with PVC cleaner. Then with a fine brush, brush some thicker PVC glue around the joint and "work it in" with a tiny screwdriver or other tool, basically "welding" the plastic. Maybe use exterior grade blue cement that is designed for less than perfect conditions (but mor messy looking)???
-Or, you could make a nice looking 2 part white epoxy joint on the leaker....I have a 20 year repair on a sawing mistake I made below our toilet once.
-Or, try silicone caulk. I think the epoxy would work better.
Again, Plumber will laugh at all this because time = money for him (his total replacement would be faster for him).
Good luck! Don't fret, because you can always repair PVC by installing an all new joint if these band aids don't work. And, in this case, there is no flood that will happen.
Be careful....PVC cleaner and glue is flammable and not good to inhale.