Polk Rti-A9 speaker buzzing, difficulty finding the problem

Joined
Feb 15, 2003
Messages
13,442
Location
Jupiter, Florida
I have a pair of Polk Rti-A9 tower speakers. Each speaker has 3ea 7 inch woofers and 2ea 5 inch midrange, and 1 dome tweeter. They are powered by an older 120WPC Yamaha receiver.

The RH speaker has a bit of a very occasional buzz (much like a blown speaker sound) on some loud music. Problem is, I can't determine where the problem lies. I believe it's one of the midrange drivers, but despite repeated effort to isolate the noise, it just does not show up when I want it to. I run over to the speaker when it happens, and by the time I get there it's gone. I just can't tell which driver it is (if any).

I've tried using a frequency sweep from 20hz to 20khz. I've also tried using the frequency generator on my phone to drive the amp at various frequencies at high volume to see if I can cause it to act up. Nothing.

I have not tried swapping the speakers Left to Right. I'll do that tomorrow. I suspect the problem will swap sides, as I do think it's a bad driver.

Does anyone have any good guidance or tricks on how to isolate the bad actor?

cGc


EDIT: I don't love the speakers. I'd give them 3 stars. Despite internet claims, the bass is weak and flat. I had to add a 12 inch sub, where my previous similarly sized speakers did not need a sub.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jan 22, 2011
Messages
7,901
I would try first swapping left and right to rule out the amplifier.. To determine which driver is rattling, remove each speaker one at a time from the enclosure. While holding the speaker (cone side) in one hand, strike the magnet on the palm of your hand. The bad speaker will rattle where a good speaker will produce a deep thud.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 14, 2011
Messages
3,352
Location
Texas
I have had problems with Polk's drivers. Their woofer drivers tend to warp voice coils.
 

Cujet

Thread starter
Joined
Feb 15, 2003
Messages
13,442
Location
Jupiter, Florida
I have had problems with Polk's drivers. Their woofer drivers tend to warp voice coils.
That's kind of what I was thinking. When the voice coil gets warm from use, it acts up a little by rubbing on the magnet. I've pushed on the drivers while operating and do not get anything unusual.
 
Joined
Nov 24, 2003
Messages
3,415
Location
Middle of Iowa
in my experience, a buzz that only happens occasionally is a spider that is starting to separate. Very hard to spot/diagnose until you pull the driver and inspect.
 
Top