We rented a 5008 and drove it around Croatia. The handling and ride quality were FAR better than they had any right to be. Nice picnic trays and hidden storage in the back seat , funky ergonomics. Great mpg, although a very tall first gear meant for a lot of clutch slip driving in mountainous towns. And I’m sure it’s because a rental but the second gear synchros were gone by 8000 kms. It’s such a disservice that we can’t get them here.
Had one in Italy. Was one of the largest vehicles Sixt offered, and had to be reserved in advance. Their "large" is our "medium."
For something the size of an X3 or Q5, way more space efficient. Neither of those could dream of carrying five people and their luggage, and have a third row jump seat if the cargo space wasn't needed.
The efficient little sub-2.0l turbodiesel only struggled with pulling away cleanly, or not stalling, on steep inclines if it wasn't given enough throttle. Clutch was also a little heavy and vague. But otherwise, it drove fine, and was happy to cruise the Autostrade all day at 80 mph, and handle the winding country roads with no issues. Was a tight squeeze in the older parts of towns, but still quite manageable. The position of the instrument cluster looks a little too high and out of place, but is actually closer to the line of sight. No other quirks.
Sometimes, you get stuck with a rental you don't really like, which detracts from the overall experience, but the 5008 worked out really well.
Also had experience with a late 70s/early 80s sedan. It, too, was spacious and comfortable; many of the same attributes, and not really quirky. The Douvrin V6 could be finicky, but when running right, was ok.
Peugeots aren't really quirky in the sense that Citroens are (at least before they became watered down under PSA), they're just a typical car with some French flavor, not really much wilder than a Volvo, Jaguar, or other non-German Euro marque is. I like German cars, but don't like how they are considered the (safe, conservative, boring, even) expected benchmark, with everything else deemed odd, or weird. Post-Ford, renaissance Volvo was smart to try to play up its own Scandinavian identity, instead of trying to ape the Germans like many others do.
From a business standpoint, it's understandable why they won't be coming back to the U.S., but too bad. The market could use some variety.