- Joined
- May 25, 2020
- Messages
- 2,751
TBNIn that case, why go for Supercar oil, when you can have Bad A$$ racing oil!?!
TBNIn that case, why go for Supercar oil, when you can have Bad A$$ racing oil!?!
Here are the numbers.
The old dexos2 version:
VII content = 7.2%
HTHS = 3.76 cP
HTFS (base-oil viscosity) = 2.50 cP
The new dexosR version:
VII content = 9.2%
HTHS = 3.53 cP
HTFS (base-oil viscosity) = 2.20 cP
So, they have really watered down this oil, making it worse in wear protection than a good ILSAC 5W-30.
Estimated base-oil viscosity (HTFS) and VII content of selected
It does seem that way. Kind of disappointing. Would be great to see their internal testing numbers for various tests like the IIIH etc.Corvettes used to use 5W-30. I see that Mobil 1 made this water-downed 0W-40 dexosR with a lot of VII and a thin base oil so that it would run more like a 5W-30 than a 0W-40. Mobil 1, unfortunately, tends to be a big believer in fuel economy, a thin base oil, and a high VII content, and they often put wear protection in the back seat.
Used to be the best, now it's awful. I get the impression Mobil just doesn't care much anymore about the marketing end. Ever since the pandemic and maybe even before that, things seem to have changed. Maybe it's all the talk of EVs LOL.The Mobil 1 website is a mess.
Used to be the best, now it's awful. I get the impression Mobil just doesn't care much anymore about the marketing end. Ever since the pandemic and maybe even before that, things seem to have changed. Maybe it's all the talk of EVs LOL.
Their website has always been awful. It's a large corporation, and someone hasn't been fired in their IT department. The person responsible for their website needs to badly rethink their priorities. Maybe a couple of complaints to the higher-ups might help the process. I don't know. Neglect has always been the hallmark of laziness and ineptitude. Job security is where it's at.Used to be the best, now it's awful. I get the impression Mobil just doesn't care much anymore about the marketing end. Ever since the pandemic and maybe even before that, things seem to have changed. Maybe it's all the talk of EVs LOL.
I thought their website was one of the best a few years ago. It's declined over the last few years though.Their website has always been awful. It's a large corporation, and someone hasn't been fired in their IT department. The person responsible for their website needs to badly rethink their priorities. Maybe a couple of complaints to the higher-ups might help the process. I don't know. Neglect has always been the hallmark of laziness and ineptitude. Job security is where it's at.
I could be wrong here, and correct me if I am... But it seems like those M1 oils shear some initially, but then stay there at that same level for the long haul. Instead of just continuously shearing to the point of failure, for example. Hope this makes sense. But that trait makes me think that initial shear is intentional, for whatever reason.It never made sense to me why Mobil makes a 0w50, 0w40 and 0w30 for racing. All are not very shear stable. XOM obviously knows this, so is this a strategy to gain some hp?
They're using a corporate CMS called Sitecore. It's pretty idiot-proof, so there is no excuse other than lack of interest and laziness (or both) to not update it constantly with accurate and complete information about their products.I thought their website was one of the best a few years ago. It's declined over the last few years though.
Modern API wizardry to combat oxidative thickening. Or you can get the same result by using thin base oils and weak polymers.But it seems like those M1 oils shear some initially, but then stay there at that same level for the long haul.
BTW, do you happen to know the TBN for that oil?
Nope. Maybe @RDY4WAR knows the TBN for HPL BAS motor oils.BTW, do you happen to know the TBN for that oil?
I would pass on the HPL PCMO Euro 0W-20 and HPL Super Car 5W-50, but the rest are mostly good.Hey, can you, when you get a few minutes, add the HPL Super Car and Euro oils to your sheet?
Nope. Maybe @RDY4WAR knows the TBN for HPL BAS motor oils.
I thought their website was one of the best a few years ago. It's declined over the last few years though.
Danke schön!
For such blasphemy you may incur the wrath of Khan!I would pass on the HPL Super Car 0W-40
So you happen to know the VII content is esp x3 0w40?I would pass on the HPL PCMO Euro 0W-20 and HPL Super Car 5W-50, but the rest are mostly good.
However, I would pass on the HPL Super Car 0W-40 as well in favor of the HPL Super Car 5W-40 or HPL PCMO Euro 5W-40—the former has the same VII content as the watered-down M1 ESP 0W-40 dexosR and only a slightly higher HTFS. Their 5W-40 grades are strong, almost as strong as the strongest 5W-40 HDEOs such as Chevron Delo 400 XSP 5W-40 and far stronger than weak 5W-40 HDEOs such as Shell Rotella 5W-40.
Estimated base-oil viscosity (HTFS) and VII content of selected oils
I would think it would be prudent to consider that an oils performance is not solely determined by VII percentage. It is the sum of all components. We are not in the business of blending with cheap materials. Also looking at UOA's you won't see a trend of our oils shearing. What it does in service my daily responsibility. What an oil does is ultimately its most important attribute. The inclusion of low VI AN's will force you to make it up in another way. The stability the AN brings will offset the higher concentration of VII which is ok if you use a good one.I would pass on the HPL PCMO Euro 0W-20 and HPL Super Car 5W-50, but the rest are mostly good.
However, I would pass on the HPL Super Car 0W-40 as well in favor of the HPL Super Car 5W-40 or HPL PCMO Euro 5W-40—the former has the same VII content as the watered-down M1 ESP 0W-40 dexosR and only a slightly higher HTFS. Their 5W-40 grades are strong, almost as strong as the strongest 5W-40 HDEOs such as Chevron Delo 400 XSP 5W-40 and far stronger than weak 5W-40 HDEOs such as Shell Rotella 5W-40.
Estimated base-oil viscosity (HTFS) and VII content of selected oils
But in comparison to your regular PCMO 0W-20 and HDEO 0W-20, your Euro 0W-20 has a lot more VII and a thinner base oil. While permanent shear can be alleviated using a high-SSI VI, temporary shear is always there, increasing wear when you have a thin base oil. Moreover, high-SSI star VIs result in increased turbocharger deposits in relatively longer OCIs in comparison to the more commonly used mid-SSI OCP VIs. See Figure 2 in the post linked below. So, there is a lot of compromise there.I would think it would be prudent to consider that an oils performance is not solely determined by VII percentage. It is the sum of all components. We are not in the business of blending with cheap materials. Also looking at UOA's you won't see a trend of our oils shearing. What it does in service my daily responsibility. What an oil does is ultimately its most important attribute. The inclusion of low VI AN's will force you to make it up in another way. The stability the AN brings will offset the higher concentration of VII which is ok if you use a good one.