Mobil 1 5w40 change or no?

[scrllock]

The test is obviously not completely representative of what oils experience inside of an engine

This is the issue. We ban project farm videos here but for some reason allow these irrelevant bench tests.

 

[JAG]

This is the issue. We ban project farm videos here but for some reason allow these irrelevant bench tests.

Moderators would make a mistake by banning volatility results for many oils, that have had generally provided accurate Noack predictions. Also, I have been a member for a very long time and used to spend a lot of time sharing educational material. A Noack result is one data point, while multiple data points are obtained in my tests. Do you think volatility is irrelevant? If so, why?

 

[Japanese]

This is the issue. We ban project farm videos here but for some reason allow these irrelevant bench tests.

Where does it say that Project Farm videos are banned?
I have posted a few or a couple of them.

 

[svenson]

best-selling is also not relevant to what 'works.' as you say, "most drivers dont judge by recipy,they dont bother to know."

and since you are replying to me, it's important to note you were the one that brought up Quaker State and motul. I was comparing Mobil 1 Full Synthetic 5w40 to 0w40 FS. In which case I do not believe there is any serious debate, except in the "which oil boils more on the stove" test. 0w40 FS is the clear flagship product for Mobil 1 Euro full saps oils. if you're going by 'most good selling' then that would also be 0w40 FS based on the online marketplace here.

i dont care about boiling and stuff...dont bother with all these references.
i am talking about some 5-40 Group III + GTL oils and are they comparable with some 0-40 with some quantity PAO oils.
so in that base ,i am comparing these 2 oils that i mention with Mobil 1 0w40 ,selling and quality-"working" good terms.

 

[Brian123]

This is the issue.

This is your Issue!

We ban project farm videos here

He is not a member here.

but for some reason allow these irrelevant bench tests.

I think Jags tests are better than the so-called Project Farms tests. Does the Project Farm tests do the same thing that Jag's test does. Is the Coffee pot test the same thing as what Jag does?
Think about something here, why is the guy on Project Farm doing YouTube videos? He could also be on this forum as a member answering questions! My thought is, if you want to be doing videos, come to this Forum and debate everyone. If you will be doing videos and not come here, then your videos mean nothing to me.

 

[thickvthin]

Seems like Mobil 1 Advanced Clean Full Synthetic 0w20 and Mobil 1 Euro 0w40 are few Mobil 1 oils left with heavy dose of gtl and pao. Rest of Mobil 1 lineup not so.

 

[edyvw]

Seems like Mobil 1 Advanced Clean Full Synthetic 0w20 and Mobil 1 Euro 0w40 are few Mobil 1 oils left with heavy dose of gtl and pao. Rest of Mobil 1 lineup not so.

Mobil 1 ESP line has PAO and GTL. 0W20 and 0W30 are PAO/GTL/Ester.