Sounds like you have your work cut out for you, lots of variables as you already mentioned. I've done piston soaks with it and had positive results, on small engines, and have one example of it freeing up rings and improving compression in a boat engine. My brother and I were talking boats, and he is at the crossroads of buying another engine. He brought up the story of an old Chevy engine and reminded me of this.
Years ago one cylinder in a Chevy 250 I6 we thought was out to lunch in my brothers boat. We ran a Compression test and in cylinder #3 and #4 it was about 20%+ lower than the others, and you could feel it in the engine, we could never get this thing to idle right. Anyway my brother was in the process of ordering a remanufactured engine for this boat. He had just bought it used to set up for offshore fishing, it was mid season and the engine swap was planned for the winter.
The Biggest problem was with salt water cooled engines you never know when the water jacket is going to rot through, so rebuilding this engine with an unknown history and over 15 years old was not an option for us. We also had some lifter noise. My brother said [censored] lets toss some MMO in the oil and run it till the end of the season, we'd stay in the bay so if it broke down getting a tow wasn't going to cost us the farm.
We used this boat for about 3 months and logged about 50 or 60 hours. The engine actually ran quite well, when we took the boat out. The lifter noise gone, and the compression in the weak cylinders came up to within 5% of the other cylinders. We swapped the engine, and now my brother is talking about doing a swap again, some 15 years later. This engine runs like a top, but the water jacket is questionable.
My brother claims he had similar success with an old Caddy Seville and MMO boosting compression, but I didn't help him with that car.
Years ago one cylinder in a Chevy 250 I6 we thought was out to lunch in my brothers boat. We ran a Compression test and in cylinder #3 and #4 it was about 20%+ lower than the others, and you could feel it in the engine, we could never get this thing to idle right. Anyway my brother was in the process of ordering a remanufactured engine for this boat. He had just bought it used to set up for offshore fishing, it was mid season and the engine swap was planned for the winter.
The Biggest problem was with salt water cooled engines you never know when the water jacket is going to rot through, so rebuilding this engine with an unknown history and over 15 years old was not an option for us. We also had some lifter noise. My brother said [censored] lets toss some MMO in the oil and run it till the end of the season, we'd stay in the bay so if it broke down getting a tow wasn't going to cost us the farm.
We used this boat for about 3 months and logged about 50 or 60 hours. The engine actually ran quite well, when we took the boat out. The lifter noise gone, and the compression in the weak cylinders came up to within 5% of the other cylinders. We swapped the engine, and now my brother is talking about doing a swap again, some 15 years later. This engine runs like a top, but the water jacket is questionable.
My brother claims he had similar success with an old Caddy Seville and MMO boosting compression, but I didn't help him with that car.