I just typically just get Frigidaire. They seem to sell a lot of them. Basically have them in all my rentals. It's basically the luck of the draw, I've had some that lasted 10+ years and then a few died after 5 years and the worst one was one that died a little over 2 years. Out of even the extended 1 year visa warranty. If the refrigerator is less than 5 years old or so and I can fix them, I fix them. Typically if the gasket is gone, I get a replacement gasket or handle if they get broken. Only time to freshen them up would be when it's empty and it's looking a little dated. I always get the standard 18 cu feet fridge with the glass shelves. I skip the icemaker, just more things to break and leak.
They all pretty much have about the same price. I used to like getting appliances at Lowes because if they had it in stock, you'd get it the next day if you ordered by 2 or 3pm. Lately with the pandemic, some of the cheap stuff has been wiped out so by the time Lowes got it in stock, Home Depot could deliver it quicker. Best Buy isn't bad if you need a dishwasher installed, you can buy an installation package that includes it. Sears wrote their own death warrant a long time ago. I used to just buy Kenmore and knew the sales guy at the local Sears. Then they got rid of free delivery so it was an extra $75. Home Depot and Lowes kept their free delivery and it was the same price so it was automatically lower. That was the end of Sears and I haven't bought any appliances from them in years. Primarily Lowes, Home Depot normally takes a couple of weeks to ship and Best Buy is usually at least a week.