Quote:
replace the timing chain and remove the pan to check for sludge plugging the oil pump pickup
It usually isn't the chain itself that's the problem. Loss of oil pressure to the main chain tensioner is what causes the chain to start slapping around and either break, or jump one or more teeth. Loss of adequate oil pressure at the main tensioner occurs primarily due to deposit formation (high temp sludge) in the gallery feeding the main tensioner. A failing con rod bearing will also cause the same thing to happen since this causes a system-wide loss of oil pressure. Yet another potential cause of loss of system-wide oil pressure comes from the internal water pump leaking into the crankcase, which forms a mayonnaise-like muck with the oil, which doesn't pump, and....same thing again.
In most cases, the broken chain is actually a casualty rather than the root cause. But when the failed engines are disassembled, the broken chain is immediately obvious and it is instantly labelled as the cause of the failure. Rarely does anyone think any further to ask what caused the chain to break. If the main tensioner or oil pressure to the tensioner hadn't failed, the chain probably would never have broken.
I've Auto-RX'd mine 3 times during the past 12 months. I also ran LC periodically and even did some so-called "flushes" with 20% LC in the crankcase. I also started using synthetic oil on a regular basis 24 months ago (other than during the ARX treatments). At this time next week, I'll have 322,500 km on it, which is an even 200K miles. That is not a huge number for some of the engines from other manufacturers, but it definitely is a big number for the 2.7.
Standard automotive oil analysis isn't much good at predicting or indicating varnish/sludge formation. The closest indicator that *I* know how to use is Oxidation. And even then I don't much about that. I know that the amount of varnish and varnish precursors increases with increasing Oxidation. So I've simply experimented with oils and OCIs that produce the lowest oxidation number possible in this engine. You can see all the data from my engine in the UOA section. The homework has already been done there; just use the data to choose from a variety of oils and OCIs.
Good luck....Phil