ShiningArcanineThey are writing a check for the market value said:
The original poster wasn't looking for a classic, however, he was looking for a loophole to buy a Jeep Cherokee and get cheap insurance.
In my eyes the replacement value is the market value, whatever it costs to replace it with the same thing (say a 1993 Cherokee with 120,000 miles) is what its market value is.
Classic car insurance takes into account market valuation and is like insuring an antique. It's a much bigger bet than regular auto insurance because an all original 1970 Dodge Charger Daytona that gets T-boned and is reparable loses much more value than just the damage because it is no longer an original car. If repaired it's still a 1970 Charger Daytona, and it is "the same position" as the owner was originally in, but it loses all the value of it being all original. It's insuring an intangible.
Regular auto insurance is based on indemnity and putting you back into the same position he was. If he has a $2500 1993 Jeep Cherokee and totals it, and a thousand dollar deductible, he will pay his deductible and get an equivalent 1993 Jeep Cherokee or a $1500 cheque to put him in the same position he was before the accident.