I'm one of the very few folks here who has been using and testing Valvoline stuff. I ran a batch of 10w30 All Climate (the plain jane dino) in my '88 Jeep Cherokee. Hard to tell how it did for a couple of reasons. I had a leak in the intake that led to slightly elevated silicon which led to slightly high wear metals. I also had an EGR malfunction that threw off the nitration numbers.
Generally, folks here feel Valvoline has a weak additive package (no moly except in diesel oils), shears quickly (mine sheared to a 20 weight in 3500 miles), and they play marketing games (like selling Synpower as a full synthetic when it is group III like Castrol Syntec). However, it had very good TBN retention in this application (no oil added and TBN was at 8).
I have had decent luck with the Durablend line in my F150's. I've had two tested with 4,000 miles. One was done as far as wear protection was concerned but it did its job and gave good wear numbers, just couldn't have gone farther. The other was exceptionally good (truck is garaged, sees more freeway miles, etc...) and will be extended to 5,000 miles this change.