Group 3 vs 4 Oil

Status
Not open for further replies.
W

west1

Joined
Dec 3, 2010
Messages
3
Location
Canada
I have am considering switching to synthetic oil on my 2.4 L Honda engine. Cold temperatures where I live. The car has a recommended Oil change interval which seems very long.

Another problem is it does burn some amount. I want to switch to synthetic. Mobil 1 (The group 4 Oil) seems to be very expensive.

Canadian Tire has re-branded Shell Synthetic (Motomaster F1 Synthetic which is a Group 3 based Oil)

I currently leave the regular group 2 oil in for about 6-7 k. I was considering getting some better filters and leaving it in for about 12-13 k.

My question is it really worth the extra money to pay the extra for the Mobil 1 when the Motomaster Formula 1 Synthetic is more than half the cost of the Mobil 1 Oil?
 
Originally Posted By: west1
I have am considering switching to synthetic oil on my 2.4 L Honda engine. Cold temperatures where I live. The car has a recommended Oil change interval which seems very long.

Another problem is it does burn some amount. I want to switch to synthetic. Mobil 1 (The group 4 Oil) seems to be very expensive.

Canadian Tire has re-branded Shell Synthetic (Motomaster F1 Synthetic which is a Group 3 based Oil)

I currently leave the regular group 2 oil in for about 6-7 k. I was considering getting some better filters and leaving it in for about 12-13 k.

My question is it really worth the extra money to pay the extra for the Mobil 1 when the Motomaster Formula 1 Synthetic is more than half the cost of the Mobil 1 Oil?


You've already posted much the same question

http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubb...397#Post2095397
 
Only difference I know,is grp III is still a dino oil and grp IV is an oil made from natural gas. How they do that,I have no idea :^P
 
Originally Posted By: west1
I have am considering switching to synthetic oil on my 2.4 L Honda engine. Cold temperatures where I live. The car has a recommended Oil change interval which seems very long.

Another problem is it does burn some amount. I want to switch to synthetic. Mobil 1 (The group 4 Oil) seems to be very expensive.


Mobil 1 is not a group 4 oil.
 
Originally Posted By: virginoil

Who cares G3 or G4 ?

It's kind of like cell phones, 4G is better than 3G and 5G will be better than 4G.............its that simple even a caveman can do it.
 
Originally Posted By: Doug Hillary
Hi,
lipadj46 - You said:
"Mobil 1 is not a group 4 oil."

Thank you, now I know!


So are you saying that mobil 1 has not gone from a primarily group 4 base oil to a group 3 (major)/group 4 (minor) mix? They laid it out so nicely in that vissom powerpoint where they claim that the vissom mixed base performs as well as a group 4 and that the conversion will be invisible to the customer.
 
There's no such thing as an oil that only uses group 4 basestock. All oils that contain group 4 contain group 3 or group 5 so that additives can be held in suspension by the oil.

Group 4 is yesterday's synthetic base stock. Group 5 Esters outperform them.
 
Originally Posted By: sangyup81

Group 4 is yesterday's synthetic base stock. Group 5 Esters outperform them.


They are comprised and engineered differently. Comparing them on a linear, progressive format would likely be illogical.
 
Can a Group III base stock oil (Castrol Syntec, Pennzoil Platinum, etc.) be labeled as Synthetic oil in Canada?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: deven
Originally Posted By: virginoil

Who cares G3 or G4 ?

It's kind of like cell phones, 4G is better than 3G and 5G will be better than 4G.............its that simple even a caveman can do it.


You have been on the forum long enough to know by now G3 or G4 means squat nowdays, its the addtitive package etc and performance of the oil that counts.

Some have reported G3 oils out perform G4 oils in certain conditions. Don't wish to debate the issue, just do a search.
 
Who really cares!

All these oils will be more then good enough to keep your cars running great for years...

The reg conventional oils like the newer Pennzoil, etc are also more then good enough to keep your newer cars running for years.

If you change out your oil every 5K-7K miles, I really do not see a difference between using the newer conventional oils and the syns...
 
XOM made is clear in a press release (post Katrina - due to a PAO shortage) they were replacing PAO base stocks with hydrocracked petroleum. There justification was that a car will not benefits from the properties of a group IV/V base stock.

Do I believe it, not in the least. They wanted an excuse to continue making profit after their PAO shortage. Hook, Line, and Sinker!
 
Originally Posted By: Unleashedbeast
Do I believe it, not in the least. They wanted an excuse to continue making profit after their PAO shortage.

That may be. But do you have proof that the new formulation protects engines any less than the old one?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

D
Mobil EP 5W based on Group 2 and 3 oil?
Replies
13
Views
745
dole
A
Penzoil vs mobil oil usage
Replies
4
Views
264
Ride_Red
P
Oil for 2.0 Skyactiv - Battle of the 0w-20
3 4 5
Replies
95
Views
7K
Dave P.
C
Supertech and other value point oils
6 7 8
Replies
156
Views
7K
rondhol
W
Feeling the difference, switching to Synthetic (PAO Group IV)
Replies
9
Views
1K
WiredForStereo
Back
Top Bottom