Good cable modem?

Status
Not open for further replies.

JTK

$100 Site Donor 2025
Joined
Aug 14, 2003
Messages
17,107
Location
Buffalo, NY
I've been renting the darn things since I started broadband service in 1999. It would save me a whopping ~$4/mo to own my own. I had a Motorola Surfboard for about 5yrs, then my provider swapped it out for a Terayon when we moved a town over. Trying to figure out if it's worth it to own my own. We use a VoIP phone serivice as well, so I'd hate to screw that up. I prefer tigerdirect for my PC needs and I see they carry only 3 different cable modems. Is Linksys any good?

Thanks for any input!

Joel
 
I've used Motorola and Toshiba cablemodems and both performed as well as you'd hope. My Linky routers have also done me well.
 
I recently swapped out my old Motorola SB4200 for a Linksys (BEFCMU10). It's been great so far. I am finally getting downloads at my advertized speeds.
 
Motorola cable modems have always been rock solid for me. I'm using a sbv4200 right now which is a voip modem, even though i don't have voip, and no complaints about it. Linksys makes top notch stuff, so while i don't have any experience with their modems, i would expect it to work just fine.
 
My ISP struck a deal with circuit city where I could buy a motorola surfboard for like $40 after rebate. You may find your local big box electronics store has stuff that works on the local cable system.

Got that modem then the rent went down from $6/mo to $3/mo shortly thereafter.
mad.gif
but it still amortized over time.
 
A whopping $4/ month for 8 years adds up. $4x8x12=$384...You could have bought almost 10 modems for that price!

When I first got cable from Adelphia, I bought for $10 from Adelphia, a Terayon TJ715 or something like that. It was a horrible modem back in 2003/4 time frame. It would constantly lose synch and thus drop my Internet connection for hours or days at a time even though there was no outage in the area. The techs came out and swapped out 5 of them only to have the same problem. One tech told me they have more problems with those than any other modem they have.
smirk.gif
Great...no wonder it was $10.

I originally wanted to rent the modem for $3/ month from Adelphia but with their $10 purchase price, that seemed to be the better deal. At the time, I thought I was only going to be here, my current duty station, for one year, not 4-1/2. I guess it worked out.

I eventually gave up calling them and found a Motorola SurfBoard 5100 for sale at Circuit City. It went for $80 with a $40 rebate. I checked with Adelphia to ensure computability, just need a Docsis 2 compatible modem. After I bought that in Apr 2004, I sold the Terayon for $50 on eBay. The Motorola has been trouble free, knock on wood, for almost 3 years now.

I have a Linksys WRT54g V2.0 that I bought in June or July 2004 and for the most part it's been trouble free. It's currently running HyperWRT + Tofu and it's rock solid. I accidentally screwed up a firmware flash once and I spent about 5 hours figuring out how to reset it and upload another firmware - almost gave up and bought a WRT54GL. What an adventure that was.
 
Last edited:
Quote:


A whopping $4/ month for 8 years adds up. $4x8x12=$384...You could have bought almost 10 modems for that price!

When I first got cable from Adelphia, I bought for $10 from Adelphia, a Terayon TJ715 or something like that..




I know. That's the sad part.
frown.gif
Funny though, I've never had an issue with my rental Terayon TJ715 that I've had since Aug 2004.

Joel
 
You want to consider the D-Link cable modem. It is DOCSIS 2.0 compliant and works well with Comcast. I have been using it for a few months now with no problems. The price at Buy.com is $46.99 after rebate, with free shipping. It connects either by Ethernet or USB. The rebate is only good until the end of the month.
http://www.buy.com/prod/d-link-dcm-202-u...1/10376165.html
 
Just an update. I picked up a Linksys BEFCMU10 from my local Target for $39.99. Just happened to stumble upon it. Last one from a closeout sale. One call to my ISP, gave the tech the MAC# from the new modem and whammo! Works like a charm. Of course this was after I lost the tech mid-stream since I was talking to him on my VOiP phone. Duhhh! Good thin he had enough time to delete the rental modem and add the new MAC# or I would have been calling them back on the cell phone. I'm getting just under the 5Mbps I'm paying for as well! The rental teryon ran 4Mbps tops. For anyone who is still renting. Don't. It's too easy to switch over to your own! I should have done it years ago.

Joel
 
Funny you post this. I just realized I am renting mine for $3/month. I have only had highspeed for about 8 months, so I have not lost too much. I am just now starting to look myself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom