Originally Posted By: opus1
Not to call anyone in particular out, but I'm constantly hearing how people with GM products have nothing but problems with them and are constantly rebuilding transmissions and so forth so I have to ask: what the heck are people doing with their cars that they need so much repair, or am I the lucky person who gets the
one well-built GM car whenever I buy one.
Probably the same things they are doing to the Toyota that are going 200K miles without repairs.
So the question is, why do folks who destroy the GM trannys or whatever, not do the same to the Toyota doing the same things.
The one transmission that SHOULD have failed for me was the Powerglide in the '66 Nova. Why? Because I was a 16 year old punk kid who beat on that car from 1981 until 1983 or 1984. I raced it as much as someone can race a 194cu in I6 with a Powerglide, etc. Did no, absolutely NO service on the transmission. It would just go and go.
I bought a used 1975 Buick Century. I think the transmission was on it's way out when I finally traded it for a 1987 (rare, not many 1987 titled) Chevy Beretta's. I think I only kept it for 6 months when I traded for a 1988 Beretta GT with a V6. It needed a new manual before the 12mo 12K warranty ran out, and it wasn't because I couldn't drive a stick. It wouldn't stay in 5th, so they replaced the transaxle.
Since I was still a punk kid, I totalled that one and got a Beretta GTZ and that had no transmission issues.
I traded that for a Dodge Neon and kept it only short while. I got married and traded the Neon for a Grand Voyager. Kept that for under 36K miles and bought a 2000 Mazda MPV. In the meantime, I had a series of beaters starting with the 81 VW Rabbit diesel I owned while I had the Beretta GTZ. Junked the Rabbit with probably 400K miles on it, but who knows. I think it had about 300K on the broken odometer when I bought it, and I likely put over 100K miles on it while I owned it.
I got a Plymouth Horizon that I had for 3 weeks when some lady decided stop signs were optional. This was after I replaced the ball joints, new tires, etc. So I got most of my money back from her insurance company. Bought what was probably my second best beater, a 1979 Ford Fairmont with about 78K miles on it, for $100. I drove it until 2000 and sold it with about 50K more miles for $500. No tranny issues with this one, but my mother had a NEW one that needed tranny work well before 100K miles and it was highway driven.
Somewhere in there, about 1996, I got married to my first wife, and her 1991 Pontiac Sunbird needed the head gasket replaced twice and the input shaft replaced on her transmission.
What kind of service prevents the input shaft from breaking?
Back to my cars, 1987 LeSabre, owned by my grandmother, but she didn't need two cars since she had a new Grand Marquis, so she sold the LeSabre to me with about 60K miles on it. GM dealer maintained, and had already needed a new A/C compressor and other work when I bought it in 2000.
Probably less than 15 months later it lunched the transmission on the Poplar Street Bridge (anyone from STL is familiar with this fine location for a breakdown) at 90,806 to the tune of a $1546.65 repair. I probably spent $1000 to keep the A/C working while I owned it, and remember, Grandma had to replace the compressor before I bought the car, $360 for a new exhaust system, and the unbreakable 3.8L V6 ground it's timing gears into metallic dust at about 116K miles, requiring another $600 in work. (This was about the time I started tracking how much I spent in car costs.)
So when I compare that to my four most recent Toyotas, there is no comparison.
I don't treat the Toyotas any different. All were maintained, and as I said, the only GM that I had for any long period of time that SHOULD have been an issue really wasn't. The 1966 Nova took the abuse of a teenage boy. My sister drove it after me. It was a "check the gas, fill the oil" kind of car, and my sister ran it out of oil at least twice. Yet it just kept running.
I needed carb rebuilds from time to time, and we had to put new bearings in the rear end. Oh, and when I piled 10 or 12 guys in the car, we broke a leaf spring.
But why doesn't GM build cars that take that sort of abuse and keep going.
I guess that's why I stuck with GM for so long. I remember the abuse that Nova got, and how it kept going.
The GM's I had that were well cared for were the ones that kept breaking on me.
So I made a change, and I've been well pleased.
Quote:
In 20+ years of car ownership, I have
never had to rebuild a tranny or even have to have engine work done, the exception being my '99 Malibu for the infamous "lower intake manifold" repair. I keep my vehicles for at least 13 years and put well over 100,000 miles on all of them. At the same time, I hear stories from people who drive imports and have off-the-wall things happen to those vehicles that they forgive because "even [Honda/Toyota] aren't perfect."
Signed,
Dazed N. Confused.