Filter Specs..

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Messages
1,460
Location
Texas
I see questions about filter specs in various threads.

Either someone is asking why they aren't "standard". Or someone posts something they have from a particular supplier.

For the record:

The current SAE testing spec for automotive oil filters is:

HS806-2001

Any filter spec you have that was not run utilizing that spec is an old test. ( Like SAE J806B)


Now that you know what the current "test" specification is, what does that mean?

SAE HS806-2001 is nothing more than a guideline on how to properly set up the test equipment before the test is actually run. Things like cleaning the equipment before running the test. Making sure the equipment is properly calibrated.

From there the filter company or OEM can specify certain test parameters including:
Flow rate
Test dust
Add rate of contaminant
Termination point of the test ( at what restriction)

These variables can be greatly effect the outcome of the test itself. Even though 3gpm is the "industry" standard flow rate, that does not mean every test is run at 3gpm.

Unless you have the full test report and the conditions the test was run under, you will have problems comparing two test results from different filters elements or different filter manufacturers.

If one company adds 5 grams of contaminant every 1/2 hour and another adds 5 grams every hour..what do you think the tests will show? Which filter has the greater "life"?

Another example--Cummins Engine Company requires the use of SOFT-C as the contaminant to run their tests. Any test operated with AC-Fine test dust will not be approved by Cummins in order to meet their specifications.

In the future you may even see ISO as the test information released. There is ongoing work between SAE and ISO to come up with a joint test program in order to create a worldwide specification for filter testing.

SAE= Society of Automotive Engineers
ISO= International Standards Organization
 
Thanks for update. Do you know what filter currently ranks the highest on the SAE HS806-2001 test?

I believe PureOne still references the SAE J806B testing on the box.
 
I suspect the Valvoline HS806 test is the same as the HS806-2001. Some companies leave off the 2001 bit as it makes the filter test look "old" as we're now 2005.

As for which filter ranks #1..you won't know.
tongue.gif


Each filter company 'adjusts' the test to show their filter better. Which is why unless you see all the test parameters, you can't compare the results.

There has been, to my knowledge, no independant lab do a filter test of multiple brands to determine which is "better".

The reason is cost, it would cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $100-250,000 to do a complete test depending on number of brands tested.

All tests are ( should be) "averages" of multiple filters tested. Not just test one filter and show the results. It takes hours to run one test on one filter. Add up the lab time..
wink.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom