The fact that people put magnets on their fuel lines and swear to significant increases in mileage sort of shows how questionable observations can be. Mileage improvements from oils are like ghosts. People swear they see them and most of them really believe it. But as soon as somebody with a camera or an instrumented test comes along, it vanishes. Look at the SSO thread to see how many people have been seeing ghosts. Obviously people are looking for an increase in mileage, and they are finding them. The increases are real but the cause is mis-attributed.
I wonder if perhaps there should be a sticky about oils and mileage, since it is coming up so much.
Real affects on mileage from differences in oils are very small. Much less than 1mpg, almost always.