Dale was a lot better than Kyle Petty. Kyle won 8 races I believe. Dale has win 26. Dale won 2 Daytona 500s to Kyle's 0. Look up all time NASCAR race wins and the list gets fairly short after more than 10 wins. Do I think Dale Earnhardt Jr is a hall of fame driver?? No. Very close but not quite there. I think him and Ricky Rudd are in the same boat so to speak. Rudd won 21 races in his career. Finished in the top 5 in points a couple of times. I think that he is very close as well as Dale in terms of being a hall of fame driver. Just not quite there.
If not for Dale Sr's money grubbing wife then DEI would have continued on and things could have potentially been different. DEI went out a long time ago due to her stupidity. I think had Dale Jr run the show there I think he would have been better served as a driver there. That being said, Steve Letarte deserves a WHOLE LOT of credit for helping Dale Jr getting back as a competitive driver again. I could tell in 09-10 that Dale was not into racing. He was just there because he had to be. In 2011 as that season wore on I could see Dale Jr starting to enjoy being at the track again. That was due to Steve Letarte helping him out a lot. In 2012 Dale seemed to really enjoy being at the track, was more engaged in what he was doing again, and certainly was competitive again as well. Even in a winless 2013 Dale stayed positive and was obviously enjoying what he was doing there at the track. When he won the 2014 Daytona 500, you could see the tremendous happiness and joy he felt. That was due to Steve Letarte's helping Dale Earnhardt Jr out so much. I give great credit to Rick Hendrick for bringing those two together because it helped Dale Earnhardt Jr personally, professionally as a driver and it made his last year's FAR more enjoyable as well.
The odds of a hall of fame professional athlete's son or daughter being as good as them are like winning the lottery. Magic Johnson's son isn't a hall of fame basketball player. Neither is Michael Jordan's son. It just isn't really likely that the offspring of a tremendously talented baseball, basketball, football, soccer, golf, tennis, NASCAR driver will ever be as good or better than their hall of fame parents. I will say that Kyle Petty was a good driver for sure. If you look at how many drivers all time have driven in the NASCAR cup series and then look at how few actually won more than 5 races then what Kyle Petty did was fairly good. He really did not do all that bad in the light of how many drivers in total NASCAR history. But compared to his father's 200 wind 8 looks to be quite small. Which it is. But again, compared to how many drivers all time that have driven in NASCAR history it is then that Kyle's 8 wins put him quite a bit higher on the list. I think Dale Earnhardt Jr's 26 wins put him a fair amount higher than Kyle. Look at how few drivers have won 20 or more races all time and that is a rather small group of drivers. Again, is he deserving of the hall of fame? I don't think so. Very close. But in comparison to his dad's 7 championships and all of his 76 wins, Dale Jr's accomplishments look rather small. When in light of the amount of drivers that have driven in NASCAR history Dale Jr's accomplishments are actually pretty impressive.