Originally Posted by Garak
In the same vein, would you be okay with Walmart selling you a jug of used oil or non-detergent 30 in a sealed Mobil 1 container, as long as the price was too good to be true? If it was $4 for a 5 quart jug, or something like that, it's okay, because you should have known it wouldn't be real M1?
Not even close to the same thing. Now you are talking about blatant deception / fraud. Buying a cheap fake for a much cheaper price is not fraud. The seller knows they are selling a knockoff, and doesn't hide that fact. And you as the buyer know you are not getting the original. You accept that, and make the purchase full well knowing it. Back to my example of the $200.00 Rolex. It's price alone screams it's not the real deal. (Just as your $4 a jug "Mobil 1" would, or should to anyone but an idiot). And as I said, if someone is stupid enough to think it is, they deserve to be scammed. Now if someone sold you a fake for the full price of an original, and deliberately lied and defrauded you, then that's deception / fraud...... 2 completely different things.
And this whole, "theft of intellectual property" is bogus as well. Because as I said, these 2 markets don't take away from each other. No one is "stealing" the others customers. The fake market attracts it's consumers. While the much more expensive original market does the same. The markets don't mix. It's like someone buying a fiberglass replica AC Cobra. They're everywhere for $55K to $90K. Where as a matching number Aluminum bodied original will sell for over $1 million.
These markets are worlds apart, and as a result don't hurt one another. Again, no one is "stealing" anything from the other. Nor is the replica hurting the "brand" of the original. Simply because anyone with an ounce of brains knows a $55K "Cobra" isn't the real deal. And the quality of these replicas is all over the place. Some are really nice, while others are junk. Again, it doesn't effect the original brand in the least.
Yet another bigger example is Harbor Freight. Most everything they sell is made in China. They don't hide it. Instead they all but brag about it. They sell direct knock offs, (fakes), of just about every power tool, generator, and gas engine in existence. Law enforcement isn't padlocking their doors shut. Honda isn't suing them over their all but exact Predator engine copies. (Which are such exact copies, many Honda parts will interchange with their Predator Models). Dewalt isn't after them for their all but exact Hercules and Bauer power drill models. They even do direct comparisons to the brand name models in their ads. Harbor Freight's business has never been better.
And one could argue that Harbor Freight is taking business away from Dewalt and Honda as a direct result. But again, there is no fraud or deception. People know and accept what they are buying. You can try to make an argument about, "brand damage". But that's not really happening either. And is only being used as a desperate form of legal leverage. Companies do this mostly for publicity. I remember some years back they uncovered a bunch of fake Cartier watches in a warehouse somewhere in New York. Cartier made a big dog and pony show out of it by having the President of Cartier drive over them with a big steamroller in front of the cameras. People were laughing.... Including him.
Most of this type of foolishness is done for attention. Which never hurts any business. As they say, imitation is the most sincere form of flattery.