Car Guru: Stop Downshift In Manual Transmissions

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: ctrcbob

70 years ago would be 1942. Back then, 99.9% of cars were manual shift. The only "automatics" were the very first Oldsmobiles that introduced the hydomatic back around 1940 (but nobody bought them) and the Dodge (Chrysler) which had the "Fluid Drive" mostly for people with handicaps, and did not have full use of their legs. I knew a woman who drove a late 1930's (think it was a 39) Dodge with the Fluid Drive. Also, don't even know if it was for sale to people without handicaps.


"Fluid drive" had nothing to do with handicap assistance at all. It was available to the general public. There were a couple of different implementations of it, and I don't remember all the subtle differences. One was still a fully manual transmission that just happened to have a fluid coupling between the clutch and the input shaft. You shifted it entirely normally EXCEPT that you didn't have to put it in neutral at a stop. Come to a stop... depress the clutch, shift from high to first, release the clutch while holding the brake. Then when you want to move, lift foot off brake and press the gas. That system was also sold by Chrysler for about 10 zillion industrial applications- everything from big forklifts to airport tugs to yard cranes. Its especially handy in things like forklifts and cranes where you have to nudge the load forward and back a few inches, then hold the brake and raise/lower. You don't have to worry about stalling the engine or riding the clutch.

The other common implementation was a dual range semi-automatic. As I recall, you left it in gear at a stop in "low" range. Drive off and when ready, lift off the gas foot slightly and it would shift to the next gear a bit like the Auburn/Cord "preselect" semi-auto. Then you did a manual shift to "high" range and repeat the foot lift when ready for 4 forward speeds.

Neither 'Fluid drive' version had a true torque convertor with a stator, they were just fluid clutches. No torque amplification other than allowing the engine to run at a higher RPM where more torque might be available. Also they were filled with engine oil, not transmission oil. They add quit a lot to the engine oil capacity, and also rejected their heat to the oiling system. That was never really a problem as far as I know.
 
Last edited:
yes on sporty/ race car yes, but not on family, grocery getter car / I have both, nice weather i drive my stick shift, and on weekday traffic i drove my suv. But i preferd auto for every day driving haha, im getting lazy, just want hit the gas and go.
 
I have my first automatic vehicle ever in 25 years of driving. I really miss rowing the gears. Although my prior vehicles were rewarding/engaging to drive in some way unlike many vehicles today.
 
Originally Posted By: CharlieJ
If it ain't got a clutch pedal, then it ain't a manual.


A sequential manual would qualify as a manual to me, provided that it's incapable of shifting without the driver's input. I don't think any of those exist on mass production street cars though.

I'd say that if it can shift itself, it ain't a manual.
 
Originally Posted By: 440Magnum
How could we possibly reverse the trend away from sticks when people seem to want the HVAC controls operated through the high-definition touchscreen (a feature of a recent rental car that thorougly p***ed me off), want bluetooth syncing of their music, voice activated everything, heated tushie warmers, and can't be bothered to take out a key to open the door (yet don't seem to mind carrying a remote fob the size of a grapefruit... I'd rather have 10 brass keys!). I just don't get it. I don't want to be locked out of my car by a $3.00 battery, I don't want to have to replace a $300 remote when (not if!) it gets run through the washer by accident, and I don't want bright screens distracting me when I try to drive at night. I don't mind luxury... I like it... but things are a little out of hand.


Sounds like your idea of luxury is mushy sofa suspension, A/C, and a radio.

Me? I'll keep my remote key fob, my bluetooth for my phone. I love the heated seats in the nox, the rear seat DVD/AV entertainment system.

The truth is, people that DON'T want the bells and whistles are in the minority these days. If you sold a boxy car (that seems to be what most BITOGers want) with A/C, no power locks, no power windows, a manual transmission only, a carbeurated OHV engine, no ABS, AM/FM radio, and nothing else, I can garuntee that sales would be lucky to be in the hundreds per month. People DO NOT want those kind of cars anymore.
 
Last edited:
I think there are a great many people - possibly even the majority - who really don't want a car at all these days. They want a flashy looking shiny thing with a comfy couch and a cellphone docking station. If the Buick Enclave cost 25% more to buy, but with twice the official MSRP rebadged as either a Mercedes or a Hyundai, well, they wouldn't be able to keep 'em on the shelves.

Oh and:
I'll have to admit that a few times lately I've enjoyed driving a car with an automatic transmission that I thought I'd hate. They were a Jeep Commander; a Jetta; a 93 Supra (with lots of performance mods); a Lexus IS. The Lexus, though, I'll say I just enjoyed so much because it was the first car I ever drove with OE seats more comfortable that the OE seats in a Fiero. Give me a pass on that one?
 
Last edited:
There is a good side to "no one" wanting a stick: I asked my local dealer to get one in with intent of purchase. I don't think he tried very hard as it never got here. On a trip out of town I stopped at a dealer and they had a 2012 marked down to 2600 below MSRP because it was a mistake, had been shipped with a standard transmission. My wife let them talk her into it with reluctance and all the while being so glad to get their mistake.
She made them throw in carpets, locking gas cap, touch up service,tinted windows, and swap out the GY tires for Michelins.
 
Originally Posted By: Nick R
Originally Posted By: 440Magnum
How could we possibly reverse the trend away from sticks when people seem to want the HVAC controls operated through the high-definition touchscreen (a feature of a recent rental car that thorougly p***ed me off), want bluetooth syncing of their music, voice activated everything, heated tushie warmers, and can't be bothered to take out a key to open the door (yet don't seem to mind carrying a remote fob the size of a grapefruit... I'd rather have 10 brass keys!). I just don't get it. I don't want to be locked out of my car by a $3.00 battery, I don't want to have to replace a $300 remote when (not if!) it gets run through the washer by accident, and I don't want bright screens distracting me when I try to drive at night. I don't mind luxury... I like it... but things are a little out of hand.


Sounds like your idea of luxury is mushy sofa suspension, A/C, and a radio.

Me? I'll keep my remote key fob, my bluetooth for my phone. I love the heated seats in the nox, the rear seat DVD/AV entertainment system.

The truth is, people that DON'T want the bells and whistles are in the minority these days. If you sold a boxy car (that seems to be what most BITOGers want) with A/C, no power locks, no power windows, a manual transmission only, a carbeurated OHV engine, no ABS, AM/FM radio, and nothing else, I can garuntee that sales would be lucky to be in the hundreds per month. People DO NOT want those kind of cars anymore.


That sounds like my Cherokee...boxy, crank windows, manual locks, no ABS (thank the Fates), no alloy wheels...it's a slushbox, unfortunately...I simply couldn't finds a 5-speed in good condition.

The day I want heated seats in a vehicle, I hope someone will be kind enough to shoot me.
 
Originally Posted By: Nick R
Originally Posted By: 440Magnum
How could we possibly reverse the trend away from sticks when people seem to want the HVAC controls operated through the high-definition touchscreen (a feature of a recent rental car that thorougly p***ed me off), want bluetooth syncing of their music, voice activated everything, heated tushie warmers, and can't be bothered to take out a key to open the door (yet don't seem to mind carrying a remote fob the size of a grapefruit... I'd rather have 10 brass keys!). I just don't get it. I don't want to be locked out of my car by a $3.00 battery, I don't want to have to replace a $300 remote when (not if!) it gets run through the washer by accident, and I don't want bright screens distracting me when I try to drive at night. I don't mind luxury... I like it... but things are a little out of hand.


Sounds like your idea of luxury is mushy sofa suspension, A/C, and a radio.

Me? I'll keep my remote key fob, my bluetooth for my phone. I love the heated seats in the nox, the rear seat DVD/AV entertainment system.

The truth is, people that DON'T want the bells and whistles are in the minority these days. If you sold a boxy car (that seems to be what most BITOGers want) with A/C, no power locks, no power windows, a manual transmission only, a carbeurated OHV engine, no ABS, AM/FM radio, and nothing else, I can garuntee that sales would be lucky to be in the hundreds per month. People DO NOT want those kind of cars anymore.


I don't know if I agree with what people want and don't want. But automakers are not catering towards older buyers who do want simpler vehicles without bells and whistles, as they're (literally) a dying demographic all the time. They are appealing to your generation instead, who loves bells, whistles, and interconnectivity.
 
No need to shoot you, Jarlaxle, you'll be old enough they can just ship you down to Florida where you won't need heated seats and won't trust that fancy air-conditioned steering wheel some other folk like so much.
 
I've ordered my vehicles new for years because that was only way to get a vehicle I wanted with a manual transmission with minimal power options, less to break
grin.gif
. My current new bought vehicles are a 1996 Ford Contour GL with a manual transmission. It does however have power door locks but without a key FOB. Also have a 2002 F-150 XL with manual transmission, manual everything, again ordered new. Now I don't think you even order a manual transmission in a F-150. In the recent past it was only in a bare bones 2 door basic model that could be had with the manual transmission.

Whimsey
 
With the economy going the way it is money will only get tighter and this will force all but the most wealthy to buy less featured cars, hopefully this will help bring some more buyers into the fold. I think a lot of folks just don't even know that manual exists in the USA so they don't even consider it.
 
Ditto!
Originally Posted By: 440Magnum
How could we possibly reverse the trend away from sticks when people seem to want the HVAC controls operated through the high-definition touchscreen (a feature of a recent rental car that thorougly p***ed me off), want bluetooth syncing of their music, voice activated everything, heated tushie warmers, and can't be bothered to take out a key to open the door (yet don't seem to mind carrying a remote fob the size of a grapefruit... I'd rather have 10 brass keys!). I just don't get it. I don't want to be locked out of my car by a $3.00 battery, I don't want to have to replace a $300 remote when (not if!) it gets run through the washer by accident, and I don't want bright screens distracting me when I try to drive at night. I don't mind luxury... I like it... but things are a little out of hand.
It floors me when my mother in law talks about her friends car that has whatever in it. I always tell her thats another $2000 repair waiting to happen. Bet my Saturn is running long after many of these new fangled electric gizmos take a place in the junkyard.
 
Originally Posted By: yonyon
No need to shoot you, Jarlaxle, you'll be old enough they can just ship you down to Florida where you won't need heated seats and won't trust that fancy air-conditioned steering wheel some other folk like so much.


I'm not that old...heck, I'm not even 40 yet. I just do not like all sorts of trouble-prone gadgets and gizmos in a car!
 
Originally Posted By: Jarlaxle
Originally Posted By: yonyon
No need to shoot you, Jarlaxle, you'll be old enough they can just ship you down to Florida where you won't need heated seats and won't trust that fancy air-conditioned steering wheel some other folk like so much.


I'm not that old...heck, I'm not even 40 yet. I just do not like all sorts of trouble-prone gadgets and gizmos in a car!


I'm not trying to call you old, just pointing out that for someone who isn't into the frills, you won't change your mind soon. A practical reason might change your mind, should that time come. I really was just trying to make a joke. My sense of humour is maybe not all that good, you know, but give me a little time. Vee hef vays uv making you lef.
 
i remember in the early 60s if you said i going to race a chevy powerglide trans, every body would LAUGH you off the track. my o my how things change.
 
I dont mind running around a rural area like I am in with a manual. Sometimes I take the Saturn out to drive; give it some exercise and freshen my mad manual skillz. (lol)
But, I cant stand it in a city. All it manages to do there is get me angry and [censored] off. Then its all downhill from there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom