Depends on your habits, budget, shape of the windshield, and weather. Blades of the same general design are more alike than different, but silicone blades do tend to last at least 3X as long before UV degradation causes cracking.
If being frozen to your windshield when turned on causes tears, silicone breaks free easier but may still be a waste of money in that case as you'll still be replacing due to the tears, and yet they generally perform better in colder weather so may still be worth the extra expense.
For a snowy environment I prefer beam style, but if you often have freezing rain creating an ice coating, true winter blades with the flexible sheath over them, can be manually cleared of ice faster. You can literally crush the ice to break it off the top, if you do so carefully. It helps to dry silicone spray and wipe their sheaths every few weeks in winter.
The video test is a bit flawed in that it is testing new blades. Rubber tends to have a release agent and will perform differently when new, compared to the majority of its lifespan, and differently at different temperatures and after different amounts of UV-oxidation hardening. At the very least he should have cleaned them off with alcohol and left them sitting out in the sun for a couple months.
What I find to be the best bet is buy the type of blade you want, from whichever brand is cheapest or most convenient at the moment, but keep a brand new spare pair in your trunk or cargo area, and tool(s) needed to change them, usually just needle nose pliers and a flashlight.