Automotive Fluids You'd Never Use

Joined
Apr 15, 2017
Messages
6,493
Location
California
I thought this might be an interesting thread. We all have our preferences for products we like and recommend, whether it's because of technical superiority, positive personal experience, or just brand loyalty, but what about those products you'd never want to use?

For me, the first three I can think of are:
-Any multi-vehicle ATF that claims compatibility with both regular automatic transmissions as well as CVTs. I'm not a hater when it comes to multi-vehicle ATF overall, but these magic fluids that supposedly work with both types of transmissions scare me. Yes I know the companies have tested it and tons of people use it, but in my vehicles or a friend or family members vehicle that I care about, absolutely not.
-Any oil additive that thickens the oil. I do think that there could be some merit to some oil additives, but all that super thick stuff like Lucas or Motor Honey etc is nasty. If you want thicker oil, put thicker oil in the car. If you really think you need thicker oil buying a 5W-40 instead of a 5W-30 is a much safer and likely cheaper choice than buying 5W-30 and putting a quart of Lucas or similar product in there.
-Washer fluid that isn't just washer fluid (such as RainX's green one). Not only do some car companies (Tesla) specifically state not to use stuff like that because it can coat the low washer fluid sensor and mess it up, but even on cars without that sensor, every time I have tried that stuff, it makes for a horrible film that causes glare from oncoming headlights when driving at night after using it. Always use the regular one (around here that's typically the blue generic one).
 
Honda/Acura specific power steering fluid (my daughter's car has a leak which I've yet to track down).

I use HPL engine oil, but sticking with OEM fluids for transmission, transfer case, and rear diff.
 
I agree with most of these.
My personal "Not Approved" list includes the following:

  • ATF/CVT fluids that are designed to meet multiple specifications. I have no confidence in them, although I did use HPL CVT fluid in my old Outback, but only after a discussion with HPL about it.
  • Any type of motor oil additive. Why come here and discuss how important it is to select a quality motor oil with a great additive pack, and then dilute that with something like Lucas or Marvel. I just don't get it. Never going to happen.
  • Any motor oil that does not meet the specification. I may break this one, in the right circumstances, with the right motor oil.
  • Coolants that meet all specifications. I only use coolants that meet the specific specification.
  • Orange Rain-X wiper fluid. I can't use it in my current cars anyway, because both my cars specify silicone free wiper fluid. But even before that, I quit using it after it stained the coolant expansion tank in one of my cars.
 
Multi vehicle ATF is good for power steering fluid in cars that are going to the wreckers in the next couple years...
Fluids from Facebook Marketplace.
Yeah, that is an odd one? The ads here usually aren't even cheaper than the sale price, and some are opened? I guess if it was a BITOG type guy's widow who is just cleaning out the garage of sealed containers, then sure I would buy in that situation, but not from the shifty guy with a lot and garage full of junk...
 
Back
Top Bottom