quote:
Originally posted by unDummy:
...Be careful with what you choose since one brand uses THAT additive that Nissan warns about. But, Nissan doesn't explain why!...
Probably because Nissan doesn't
have to. Nissan doesn't have to provide a warranty either. (Contrary to conventional "wisdom", a warranty is
not a legal requirement for doing business. Warranties are nothing more than marketing tools. However, if a manufacturer elects to offer a written warranty for competitive reasons, they are perfectly free to stipulate the conditions under which warranty claims will be honored.) As an owner, you can pay 'em now (for their proprietary fluid), or you can chance paying 'em later (for a tranny rebuild). Your car, your choice.
quote:
...I don't know what the issue is with all the fluids. Most transmissions, new and rebuilt, have similar components of manufacture. The only issue is in the programming(VB and TCU)...
Don't forget that friction materials differ considerably between manufacturers. That, in turn, requires differences in the quantity and type of friction modifiers. (Are manufacturers intentionally manipulating friction material compounding to force owners to tow the proprietary, pricey fluid party line? Of course! Like warranties, it's another business decision. Whoever said life is fair? Get over it.) Dexron III is formulated with a considerably lower amount of FMs that fit GM transmissions to a "T". For years the Dexron fluids were considered "universal" ATFs, but that simply is no longer true with current ATs. At best, Dexron III may provide marginally harsher shift quality - which for some owners may be preferable. At worst, it can destroy a trannie. (Don't believe that? Run Dexron III, in either conventional or Mobil 1 syn iterations, in a late Mopar AT.)
In any event, running ATF+3 in a transmission marginally specified acceptable to run Dexron III is asking for trouble. Even the ATF+3 bottles specifically state the fluid's neither recommended nor acceptable for Dexron III applications.