This thread has taken some twists and turns. Maybe we need a thread for each product, and how the use of that specific non-OE product, could possibly effect your warranty. This thread got me thinking about the oil filter type I am currently using...
Back to the API topic...
There are cases, here on this forum, where using non-API certified products, were proven to decrease engine wear and tear, and in some cases, prevent catastrophic failure.
There is no way, as far as I know, that testing for API compliance, on a used oil sample, could possibly be done, or would ever be attempted, or even thought of as an option.