Another PureOne 14610

Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Silver02ex

Joined
Sep 15, 2004
Messages
824
Location
West Coast
This one was on my 02 Civic for 5,000 miles. 6 months, during Oregon's winter. Driving consist of 20+ miles highway to idle for 5-10 mintues and short trips. I replaced the filter with a Fram Extended Guard.

dscn2843m.jpg

dscn2844c.jpg
 
Last edited:
Looks Good to me, thanks for the Pics!

Hope the Fram will serve you well too.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: shrooms
You could've went 7500, no prob. 5K is nothing for that filter and oil for a Civic.


I know I could. Most of the time I change it 5,000/6 months.
 
Originally Posted By: 123Saab
Looks Good to me, thanks for the Pics!

Hope the Fram will serve you well too.


It's has in the past. I'm more impress with the Fram than the P1.
 
Originally Posted By: Silver02ex
"...... I'm more impress with the Fram than the P1.


What's the price difference between the two filters?
 
Originally Posted By: dkryan
Originally Posted By: Silver02ex
"...... I'm more impress with the Fram than the P1.


What's the price difference between the two filters?


$6 regular price for the P1 at our local Bi-Mart or K-Mart. $9 ish at Wal-Mart normal price for the Fram. I got a bunch of Fram when it was on sale.
 
Looks good, the 14610 has lots of media for it's size. P1 regular price ~$6, but with very little effort can be had for ~$3-$5 max at AAP. XG is a good filter too, but I wouldn't spend $9 for an XG for 5k OCI. Just me.

Thanks for the pics.
 
Originally Posted By: sayjac
Looks good, the 14610 has lots of media for it's size. P1 regular price ~$6, but with very little effort can be had for ~$3-$5 max at AAP. XG is a good filter too, but I wouldn't spend $9 for an XG for 5k OCI. Just me.

Thanks for the pics.


The nearest AAP is probably 1,000+ miles away. I can't find P1 14610 for under $5 around where I live, that's even with a sale. I wouldn't pay $9 for a XG also. I got a bunch of them when they had a rebate from Fram.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: Silver02ex
Originally Posted By: sayjac
Looks good, the 14610 has lots of media for it's size. P1 regular price ~$6, but with very little effort can be had for ~$3-$5 max at AAP. XG is a good filter too, but I wouldn't spend $9 for an XG for 5k OCI. Just me.

Thanks for the pics.


The nearest AAP is probably 1,000+ miles away. I can't find P1 14610 for under $5 around where I live, that's even with a sale. I wouldn't pay $9 for a XG also. I got a bunch of them when they had a rebate from Fram.


Any K-Mart's near you?
 
Originally Posted By: ltslimjim
Originally Posted By: Silver02ex
Originally Posted By: sayjac
Looks good, the 14610 has lots of media for it's size. P1 regular price ~$6, but with very little effort can be had for ~$3-$5 max at AAP. XG is a good filter too, but I wouldn't spend $9 for an XG for 5k OCI. Just me.

Thanks for the pics.


The nearest AAP is probably 1,000+ miles away. I can't find P1 14610 for under $5 around where I live, that's even with a sale. I wouldn't pay $9 for a XG also. I got a bunch of them when they had a rebate from Fram.


Any K-Mart's near you?

Yes, but like I said, even the sale price there is still $5
 
Originally Posted By: Silver02ex
Originally Posted By: ltslimjim
Originally Posted By: Silver02ex
Originally Posted By: sayjac
Looks good, the 14610 has lots of media for it's size. P1 regular price ~$6, but with very little effort can be had for ~$3-$5 max at AAP. XG is a good filter too, but I wouldn't spend $9 for an XG for 5k OCI. Just me.

Thanks for the pics.


The nearest AAP is probably 1,000+ miles away. I can't find P1 14610 for under $5 around where I live, that's even with a sale. I wouldn't pay $9 for a XG also. I got a bunch of them when they had a rebate from Fram.


Any K-Mart's near you?

Yes, but like I said, even the sale price there is still $5


Sorry, didn't see that. Lame, my K-Mart has them just under $5 before tax. I live in metro-Atlanta.
 
sayjac said:
Looks good, the 14610 has lots of media for it's size. P1 regular price ~$6, but with very little effort can be had for ~$3-$5 max at AAP. XG is a good filter too, but I wouldn't spend $9 for an XG for 5k OCI. Just me.

+1.....At a 5000 OCI...the P1 is all the filter you need. Just look how great it is

With Bi-Mart price of $5.79, ond on sale for $1 off (now $4.79).....and a $2 Purolator Rebate (coming up soon.....you can get P1's for under $3.00.

The only way I would spend $9 for an XG.....is if my OCI's would be near 10,000 miles. That would make sense.
_________________________________________
03' Ford Focus (2.3L Duratec) 95k
M1 5w20EP / M1 102EP Filter / OCI: 10K +/-
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
Quote:
Just look how great it is
True. Hardly looks used even at 5k. As pointed out, looks like it could easily have done 7.5k, no problemo.
thumbsup2.gif


As for P1 cost, a great majority of the US can get them for the $3-5 cost mentioned. Amazon also frequently has them for $5 with free shipping for a $25 order. Kmart ~$5 on sale.

But, based on the comments here the OP clearly prefers the XG, which is fine. Also for his complete satisfaction, likely what he should use in the future. That said, doesn't diminish how good the posted P1 looks, and the overall value for construction/efficiency of the filter.

fwiw, getting ready to pull a P1 with ~7k/9month OCI, 10-15% Honda MM. Will post pics.
 
Originally Posted By: sayjac
Quote:
Just look how great it is
True. Hardly looks used even at 5k. As pointed out, looks like it could easily have done 7.5k, no problemo.
thumbsup2.gif


As for P1 cost, a great majority of the US can get them for the $3-5 cost mentioned. Amazon also frequently has them for $5 with free shipping for a $25 order. Kmart ~$5 on sale.

But, based on the comments here the OP clearly prefers the XG, which is fine. Also for his complete satisfaction, likely what he should use in the future. That said, doesn't diminish how good the posted P1 looks, and the overall value for construction/efficiency of the filter.

fwiw, getting ready to pull a P1 with ~7k/9month OCI, 10-15% Honda MM. Will post pics.


Oooh, please!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

WiskyBadger
Fram Ultra 10575 cut open
Replies
10
Views
583
Bill7
TrainingPolicy
2010 Toyota Highlander - PG5608EX 5.7k mi
Replies
2
Views
207
dnewton3
Sidebite
Ford FL-820S C&P and Walmart FL1A Filter Observations
Replies
9
Views
1K
Fair enough
Rand
C&P of Fram Titanium FS10060 from 2020 Ram 1500 5000miles on VRP first run.
Replies
7
Views
371
Rand
9
2024 tacoma oil service question
2
Replies
38
Views
2K
edyvw
Back
Top Bottom