Originally Posted By: BrocLuno
OK, so I don't build Caddy's... I mostly build BBCs
And I use old school flat tappets/cams. I use either new Delphi (GM) lifters or if going more aggressive, I use Crower Cam Saver or Howard's Direct Lube lifters.
But I got this message from a bud down under (Australia) and his experience in building V8 Sedan Race motors (flat tappet limited by rules)...
Broc,
If you want your new cam & lifters to last, then have a set of stock lifters re-faced.
In this country, because of the high cost of new FT lifters, we re-face them & have done for DECADES. I have personally used lifters that have been re-faced 2 or 3 times, zero problems, good as new. [ Contrary to popular belief, FT lifters are the same hardness right through ].
We found out about 15 years ago that the lobe/lifter failures were not oil related...............although the oil companies saw a marketing opportunity & the suckers came...& came.....& they're still coming!
The problem is the lifters. Soft metal, no radius, wrong radius, radius off centre. It makes no difference if they are brand name lifters or not, still off-shore rubbish. I had Comp & Crower lifters fail first time in nearly 40 yrs of engine building. Even trying the humble centre punch test on the bench & comparing it a stock lifter, you could SEE the soft metal displaced around the punch mark.
I send my lifters interstate for re-facing, as the bloke I use specialises in it. Because he does 000s of them, he quickly saw the problem arise years ago.
In your country, for lifter re-facing, you would probably need to find someone who specialises in re-cond of older engines, where old parts need to be re-used.
So if you want a reliable set of FT lifters, have your stock lifters [ or any made prior to about 1995 ] re-faced.
Cheers, Geoff.
So I'm trying to find a shop here in the USA that still does tappet refacing... If not I'll ship to OZ. It'll be a wash on price of new Crowers vs rebuilt pre-1995 OEM lifters. But it's a good source/idea cause you just can't trust modern flat tappets except a few ... Having a lifter failure
will kill an engine. And there is too much of that going around
Point being as you tear these engines down, save the lifters and and either have them refaced, or sell them on eBay to someone who will
Keepin the old school stuff happy is cool
And for oil - I'd use Valvoline Maxlife 10W-40 (red bottle) year round. Cheap enough at WalMart and it's building a good reputation as a go-to lube for older flat tappet motors, even if freshly built
Interesting-if you have this guy's company name & address, it would be good to know. GM engines have been munching cams since at least the '80s (I had 2 do it, a Buick 350 & Chevrolet SB 305), he might be on to something.