Because you live in hot Texas the reason you skipped over trying the 5w30 first?
The jump you made was huge...... cst roughly 8.5 to cst roughly 14.5. I would have started around 11.5 Is your 5w40 SP?
It is SP rated but if it wasn't I wouldn't mind since my engine's not lspi prone nor burning the thicker oil. Wasn't so much the heat because if peak summer temps were 20f lower where i lived i'd've still used a 3.5+ hths oil anyway knowing thickie me. I only lost about 0.2 maybe 0.3 mpg tank average compared to the same season with 0w-20. Seems very worthwhile to me. I used to use 10w40 and 20w-50 instead of 5w-20 in both my old fords just for the heck of it even though they didn't burn oil.