Its my belief that Good condition, Tight clearance 4.0s do run better with a 10w-30, or even a 5w-30 in cooler temps. Ive had a handfull of these 4.0s in my time, two of which I still have now, one of which is my 99 with its Freshly Built 4.0 that Im driving today, the other being my Beloved 2001 SilverStone Metallic Jeep Cherokee with its 64,606 mile 4.0. Neither of these Good, Tight engines "Mind" thicker oil(Custom Break-In Oil for the 99 was somewhere in the low Straight 30s), and I have put 15w-40 Diesel oil in my 01, with Good results actually. My 01 has Quaker State 10w-40 in it right now. I do believe that High Mileage, Severe useage 4.0s DO like heavier weight oils like Straight 30s, Diesel 15w-40s, and even 20w-50 weight oils to "Fill" in the gaps between Worn moving parts. Those Newer, Tight tolerance engines discussed before might make noise with thicker oils because they are not getting suffecient oil to their Tight Tolerance moving parts. Thats my humble opinion, Im only right about half the time anyways. I use 10w-30 or 10w-40 in Good Jeeps with 4.0s, and Straight 30 usually in Worn Jeeps.