For me, I want a reasonable HTHS, i.e. roughly 3.0 or above for my applications, but I also have to have the number before the "w" in the SAE grade to be suitable for my climate. Sure, I like to see a higher TBN and a lower Noack, and there's nothing wrong with a good VI. But, if I can't use the oil year round, there isn't a lot of point in me purchasing it.