We decided to go with the 3D MAXpider set. It arrived yesterday (2 day shipping via Amazon Prime) and we are extremely happy.
We LOVE the fit, apparent quality, texture of finish. It's a fake weave done well offering a sophisticated look.
It's just perfect to have a GREAT LOOKING option.
The grippy bottom surface does bite right into the carpet. They set into place as if locked down. They almost don't need a grippy bottom.
That's not to say we dislike the "serious-cleaty" look of the Weathertechs and others. They do hold water but can grab the shoes of lazy or old people.
FIRST HAND HISTORY:
Weathertechs have gone into two Jeep Cherokees.
I've had the option to buy look-a-like Weathertechs (driver's only) for a Saab 9-5 on two occasions.
I wish I could recall the name of the company which offered single mat sales because they deserve to be thanked in public.
I bought my sister the Husky set for her 2012 Mazda3, offering a great comparison for us. They're of a harder but still flexible plastic.
I put Rensi brand foot well inserts in my Volvo V70. Limited due to size but OK. Anyone would want more coverage. Comparable material to the Husky set
The 3D MAXpider set shares the top shelf with the Weathertechs possibly having an edge in passenger cars vs. trucks.
They look and feel great.
I recommend them. Check to see if they're made for your car.
SO, I conclude "We the People" have it pretty good because we got 'choice';
Hugs and kisses to you all. Kira