I think you would be very pleased with the Contis. You stated that you have a different winter tire set, and mediocre snow performace is really the Contis only weakness. Mine have been the best riding and best wet performing ATs I've owned. Bonus, on my Jeep Commander they currently have about 34k miles and probably still have another 20 or 30k of life in them. All other ATs I've used in past were shot by about 30-32k.