My 2 cents:
*** When new.
Most of those 2nd tier tires start to noticeably deteriorate after a few years of age hardening and wear.
Falken has stepped up their game considerably in the last 5+ years.. But a half worn one likely isn't close to a half worn michelin or continential..
if comparing similar tires.
Those Sincera sn250 are an interesting budget option as they are priced well.. but average or below in winter..
Not saying tire rack is doing anything wrong but it is hard to test all metrics of tires.
You cant tell me anyone with braincells really thinks a falken sincera sn250 is that much better than a michelin defender 2.
but there is no easy way to figure out how much performance is retained after 3 years on the road either.