Can you clue us all in on the secret to not getting the 25% assigned to work on your car? Or the ones that got 15 minutes of "training" and were let loose?
I've ruptured sockets, by hand, trying to get overtorqued lugs off, so I leave little to chance when it comes to this. Doesn't take much effort to spin lugs on by hand, then torque them, but then, I don't work in a shop and have to speed through a queue.
Too many possibilities for miscues, including from the OP, whose tech misread the spec, to assume anything.