Originally Posted by SteveSRT8
Originally Posted by JHZR2
Imagine the fuel economy if towing too! Let's be sure we are comparing apples to apples here.
The physics of higher load resulting in higher energy use is not earth shattering, nor unique to one approach.
You forgot to mention sitting and recharging for a while when that same F-150 can easily and quickly refill his fuel tank. That's a real deal breaker for truck users like myself.We use thousands of dollars per month in fuel. It would cripple our schedule to have so much downtime. Many times one truck comes in and goes right out again with another driver. Quick turnaround! Just comparing "apples to apples", IMO a difficult stretch here as the vehicles are quite different in real world usage.
Actually, my principal belief about most electric vehicles is the potential for long life with much less servicing. That could be a real advantage.
I always enjoy your posts Steve.
Agreed, the commercial operators needs aren't yet met on fueling speed equivalence.
The gap is closing fast though - 250 miles range in 15 minutes is getting there.
On actual use - 80-90%+ of the 1/2 ton trucks driving around have nothing in the bed, and nothing on the hitch.
It's being used as a car, or at a very low % of its total capacity and a car, suv or midsized truck would suffice.
After living with a couple different teslas on trips now - I'd say the average pickup guys needs are met with an electric.
Towing, not yet -
Hauling to and from home depot or a lumberyard, something like a pool guy on a day route absolutely better met with an electric.
Until one has had a vehicle that begins every day with a full "tank" its easy to discount this as the HUGE upside it really is.
This is the magic part of the scenario where the electric ALWAYS wins over the gas vehicle.
At end of the day you drive home, or back to the office - not to a gas station.
If you skip that gas station trip at night - you have to do it in the morning- you have to pay that piper with a trip specifically dedicated to fueling.
Something like 90% of light duty truck work doesn't involve multiple fillings a day, more like a few a week.
The more fillings a week the more time you save by starting each day with a full tank - until you get to multiple fillings a day scenario where the electric takes longer only then do you actually go backward on time - until that moment you gain time (by avoiding a dedicated fuel stop) every filling at night.
For joe weekend average guy what is more common - guys that fill a couple times a week, or those that full multiple times a day?
In EVERY scenario that doesn't involve multiple fillings a day, or towing long distances - the electric runs away with the livability and cost to operate per mile prize hands down.
UD