Well guys I want to switch over to Pennzoil or Quaker State High Mileage...would it be safe? Truck has over 220k now on a chevy 5.3 l33! Right now I'm using maxlife 5w30 and a Bosch filter..is if safe to switch to Pennzoil? I want to give my motor a good clean out! I drive short trips averaged 10 miles a day, lots of stop and go traffic!
Switching to penzoil or quakerstate
- Thread starter Chevy538487
- Start date
- Status
Yes its safe if that's what you want to do. Why in the world wouldn't it be?
Are you switching because you think the Pennzoil is going to clean it out? Seems like Maxlife has worked well so far. I wouldn't change anything.
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2008
- Messages
- 5,524
Originally Posted By: Chevy538487
is if safe to switch to Pennzoil? I want to give my motor a good clean out!
*sigh*
is if safe to switch to Pennzoil? I want to give my motor a good clean out!
*sigh*
I always had good results from pennzoil high mileage in the past and may be still using it if they improved their leaky jugs with an inner seal..
Max life is also a good oil why do you want to switch? Valvoline makes a good product and their oil jugs are safer with a good seal.
Look at the max life PDS online and compare that to Pennzoil if you can find a recent pennzoil pdf that is.. I could not.
Max life is also a good oil why do you want to switch? Valvoline makes a good product and their oil jugs are safer with a good seal.
Look at the max life PDS online and compare that to Pennzoil if you can find a recent pennzoil pdf that is.. I could not.
Originally Posted By: czbrian
Are you switching because you think the Pennzoil is going to clean it out? Seems like Maxlife has worked well so far. I wouldn't change anything.
Just curious at the results I could get..was using Mobil 1 but got tired of 70$ oil changes
Are you switching because you think the Pennzoil is going to clean it out? Seems like Maxlife has worked well so far. I wouldn't change anything.
Just curious at the results I could get..was using Mobil 1 but got tired of 70$ oil changes
Originally Posted By: Chevy538487
Originally Posted By: czbrian
Are you switching because you think the Pennzoil is going to clean it out? Seems like Maxlife has worked well so far. I wouldn't change anything.
Just curious at the results I could get..was using Mobil 1 but got tired of 70$ oil changes
Buy your oil at Walmart. Mobil 1 is $22-$25 for a 5 quart jug, not sure of the specific price at this time. Pick up a FRAM Ultra filter while you are there to go with it.
But yeah, you can switch to a different oil if you want to. No big deal but I am sure the MaxLife is doing just fine for your engine.
Originally Posted By: czbrian
Are you switching because you think the Pennzoil is going to clean it out? Seems like Maxlife has worked well so far. I wouldn't change anything.
Just curious at the results I could get..was using Mobil 1 but got tired of 70$ oil changes
Buy your oil at Walmart. Mobil 1 is $22-$25 for a 5 quart jug, not sure of the specific price at this time. Pick up a FRAM Ultra filter while you are there to go with it.
But yeah, you can switch to a different oil if you want to. No big deal but I am sure the MaxLife is doing just fine for your engine.
Originally Posted By: Chevy538487
Just curious at the results I could get..was using Mobil 1 but got tired of 70$ oil changes
Wow where are you taking it that it costs $70 for a change? Because surely it isn't costing you that much to do it yourself.
And you say you want to give it a good clean out. You know it needs cleaning?
Just curious at the results I could get..was using Mobil 1 but got tired of 70$ oil changes
Wow where are you taking it that it costs $70 for a change? Because surely it isn't costing you that much to do it yourself.
And you say you want to give it a good clean out. You know it needs cleaning?
Mobil 1 is reasonable at wal mart plus i believe there is a $12.00 rebate...
For that price Mobil 1 is a clear winner.
For that price Mobil 1 is a clear winner.
Originally Posted By: crazyoildude
Mobil 1 is reasonable at wal mart plus i believe there is a $12.00 rebate...
For that price Mobil 1 is a clear winner.
It's not that clear a winner as PP is $22.88 at W/M with a $10 mfg rebate. Witin $2 of each other or 40c per quart. Whichever floats your boat.
All 3 products have different chemistry. M1 high magnesium/low calcium/moly + boron. PP higher calcium/no Mg/moly + boron. Valvoline high sodium, moderate calcium, no moly, no boron. While I think it is preferential to stick with one chemistry over time, there's no real risk in switching oils. It's probably more risky to mix them as the resultant chemistry will be untested.
Pqia tests
Mobil 1 is reasonable at wal mart plus i believe there is a $12.00 rebate...
For that price Mobil 1 is a clear winner.
It's not that clear a winner as PP is $22.88 at W/M with a $10 mfg rebate. Witin $2 of each other or 40c per quart. Whichever floats your boat.
All 3 products have different chemistry. M1 high magnesium/low calcium/moly + boron. PP higher calcium/no Mg/moly + boron. Valvoline high sodium, moderate calcium, no moly, no boron. While I think it is preferential to stick with one chemistry over time, there's no real risk in switching oils. It's probably more risky to mix them as the resultant chemistry will be untested.
Pqia tests
Originally Posted By: Bottom_Feeder
Originally Posted By: Chevy538487
is if safe to switch to Pennzoil? I want to give my motor a good clean out!
*sigh*
+1 if you are using max life you won't gain any cleaning switching to pennzoil. You are already using a highly regarded Dexos rated oil.
Originally Posted By: Chevy538487
is if safe to switch to Pennzoil? I want to give my motor a good clean out!
*sigh*
+1 if you are using max life you won't gain any cleaning switching to pennzoil. You are already using a highly regarded Dexos rated oil.
Originally Posted By: Bud
Use whatever oil you want. Whatever brand you want. Mix if you so desire. Your engine won't know the difference.
+1
First I've heard not being able to mix oils... and magic sludge removal! I got some blinker fluid to sell you
Use whatever oil you want. Whatever brand you want. Mix if you so desire. Your engine won't know the difference.
+1
First I've heard not being able to mix oils... and magic sludge removal! I got some blinker fluid to sell you
Originally Posted By: Bud
Use whatever oil you want. Whatever brand you want. Mix if you so desire. Your engine won't know the difference.
I agree. I have mixed oils (5 different brands at one time before) and rarely use the same oil more than twice in a row. Syn, blend, dino, I don't care, and my engines don't either.
Use whatever oil you want. Whatever brand you want. Mix if you so desire. Your engine won't know the difference.
I agree. I have mixed oils (5 different brands at one time before) and rarely use the same oil more than twice in a row. Syn, blend, dino, I don't care, and my engines don't either.
crazyoildude said:I always had good results from pennzoil high mileage in the past and may be still using it if they improved their leaky jugs with an inner seal..
Max life is also a good oil why do you want to switch? Valvoline makes a good product and their oil jugs are safer with a good seal.
Really!!!
yeah really Malo...
Like they say you learn something everyday today you learned about poorly sealed Pennzoil jugs.. Tomorrow who knows .
Like they say you learn something everyday today you learned about poorly sealed Pennzoil jugs.. Tomorrow who knows .
69gtx These days i lean toward Mobil 1 over Pennzoil.. Mobil 1 is everywhere and they list their pds on their website which is a plus..
Thank you for the PQIA link but that is from back in Feb.2013 over 3 years ago which is the latest i have seen on pennzoil so far without jumping through hoops.
Im sticking with Mobil 1 for now.
Thank you for the PQIA link but that is from back in Feb.2013 over 3 years ago which is the latest i have seen on pennzoil so far without jumping through hoops.
Im sticking with Mobil 1 for now.
Originally Posted By: bmwpowere36m3
First I've heard not being able to mix oils... and magic sludge removal! I got some blinker fluid to sell you
They are miscible but it is not optimal.
As Shannow has pointed out, you get an oil with zero certifications.
First I've heard not being able to mix oils... and magic sludge removal! I got some blinker fluid to sell you
They are miscible but it is not optimal.
As Shannow has pointed out, you get an oil with zero certifications.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked