Suck or Drain Oil?

Messages
238
Location
Girard, Ill
What is the most effective procedure for draining oil, draining from bottom or sucking out by a hand pump extractor? Would a hand pump or air pressure pump be most effective?
 
Messages
2,493
Location
MSP 'burbs, MN
What kind of car are we talking about? With some cars, you can actually extract more of the used oil through the dipstick versus draining...although I don't believe that is the norm.
 
Messages
7,775
Location
Oklahoma
Drain. Unless your dipstick tube is threaded whereas you can screw on an extractor like on Mercruiser engines or you just can't get to it, you should drain it after it's warmed up.
 
Messages
142
Location
Atlanta
With an extractor I can do a no filter change OCI in 10 minutes without getting dirty or crawling under anything. I can get 4.4 out of the 4.7 quarts this way.
 
Messages
9,427
Location
Pensacola & Vero Beach FL
I used to do extractor changes when I still had a 98 Regal GS. I would get out virtually the same +/- 5 qts of oil, and I could easily reach the oil filter through the passenger-side wheel well. This made oil changes absurdly easy. On later vehicles, either threading difficulties, or unreachable filters made it to where it was not worth doing it this way. I guess it all depends upon the vehicle.
 
Messages
357
Location
none
You won't know until you do it with an extractor (vacumn) down the dipstick and then double check by pulling the drain plug. So far, for me, I'm 2 for 2. Each time it was bone dry when pulling the plug. Others have reported up to a 1/2 quart - so your stuck with the drain method. I bought mine from JerryBeach.com - they have Pella 6000 on sale right now for $36. Works great - and will come in handy on lawnmower and motorcycle oil changes which are a real pain.
 
Messages
187
Location
Central Texas
Put the vehicle on ramps to maximize the amount of oil through the plug and you can get 99%. If you have to get under the car anyway to reach the filter it makes no sense to use a pump. Put a Fumoto drain valve on it so you just attach a hose,place the end in a empty 5 qt jug and open the valve. It doesn't get much easier.
 

Kestas

Staff member
Messages
13,952
Location
The Motor City
Some makes (Mercedes, VW) have designed the engine so extraction is favored... they make an awful mess when you pull the drain plug, oil hits the suspension and other components. And as Andy said, you can get as much out with an extractor.
 
Messages
5,763
Location
Da Swamp
I'm a confirmed extractor. (I almost wrote sucker!) I used to do the classic drain method, and it worked fine on any car which was high enough off the ground for me to get to the drain plug and filter. But then, while changing oil on my late beloved MB 420SEL, the plastic drain pan -- you know the kind, a 10-qt. pan with a screw-on cap and a closing lid, so you can take the whole thing to recycling -- the pan, as I say, began to *leak*. Not a small leak, a steady nasty flow. Sure, I could have brought it back to AutoZone for a refund . . . but I would have had to empty it first! Good thing it started to leak *before* I put it in my trunk! I finished the change, disposed of the oil (never mind how), and bought a Topsider the next day. When I'm done with a change, I seal up the big metal can and bring it to AZ for recycling. In between changes, it sits -- clean -- in its box in the closet. And it can be used to suck out other fluids, too! Paul
 
Top