It's a 2.4. It doesn't get great gas mileage to begin with. It's rated 21 MPG City from the from the factory. I've been getting close to 24 with nothing on, in nice weather. Also, it has a spring-loaded automatic tensioner.1.8 engine? My wife's 2010 non-GT would average about 22 with almost all city driving in the summer.
If this is a 1.8, do check the belt. Ours didn't have a tensioner--it was tightened the old school way at the alternator bracket.