The risk with a closeout filter is that it has had a longer period to sit around and absorb the various odors in an auto parts storehouse -- rubber, oil, chemicals, etc. -- and may retain that smell, at least temporarily, and hopefully not permanently.
BTDT with such an RA filter, and there's a thread buried here somewhere about it, but mine did clear up after a few days.
OTOH, a non-closeout filter could have been sitting in the same kind of environment just as long.