Refilling printer cartridges

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 14, 2003
Messages
8,708
Location
Nothern USA
Anybody refill your own printer cartridges? What sort of luck have you had? I know we have reloaders here. Specifically HP 56 and 57? I have had a an HP psc 2175 for several months. Last night while copying some stuff, I got a low black ink message.

At one time I had an Epson printer and I was refilling cartridges for it. Before long it quit working. It has a separate printing head that is not replaced when you replace the cartridge. All you buy is a funny little bottle of ink, but it is still as much as the cartridges that have a new print head. shouldn't it be safe to at least try refilling the HP?

I trust BITOG members more than people that hang out around computer forums.
 
last year I did some math and discovered the cost of printing the fairly large amount we do.
investigated the options and...........
threw out my working HP855.
bought a Canon i560.
HP inkjet OEM = $27
discount part about $23
no real options past this point, terrible results attempting refilling HP type cartidges
Canon black inkjet $13
discount part $11.
123inkjets.com part $5
buying small quantities with discounts etc I am now averageing $3.30 or less from this supplier.
not bothering with refilling
.......shoulda threw that old printer out years ago.......
 
quote:

Originally posted by labman:
Anybody refill your own printer cartridges? What sort of luck have you had? I know we have reloaders here. Specifically HP 56 and 57? I have had a an HP psc 2175 for several months. Last night while copying some stuff, I got a low black ink message.

At one time I had an Epson printer and I was refilling cartridges for it. Before long it quit working. It has a separate printing head that is not replaced when you replace the cartridge. All you buy is a funny little bottle of ink, but it is still as much as the cartridges that have a new print head. shouldn't it be safe to at least try refilling the HP?


I had the same experiance with refilling Epson cartridges, but then I also had another couple year old Epson just quit printing on me when it had never seen anything except Epson Ink.

I'm paranoid about refilling my HP 56,57 and 58 cartridges. Maybe some ARx or LC in the ink would help
smile.gif
.
 
No luck refilling cartridges. The slightest air bubble screws everything up.

I look at it this way: HP is a printer company. More than half their revenue is based on printers and related consumables. You just can find cheap replacement cartridges, they own the market on pricing. In a 3-4 year lifespan, the life of a printer in the average home nowadays, it's a fair amount cheaper to buy a new Canon model than it is to buy an HP and their expensive cartridges. My suggestion: dump the HP printer, you'll be glad you did.

As an aside...
I've switched all my network laser printers to Xerox 3450's & 8400 models. And all HP inkjets are being given the heave-ho in favor of Canon models. Canon is unmatched for cheap & long lasting ink cartridges. I have a BJC 8200 I just can't get rid of because it works and costs so little to maintain.

Check out the Canon i960 photo printer. Tomshardware.com had a good review & gave it a thumb's up. From newegg.com, it's cheap, too!
smile.gif
 
I bought HP because the only choices for Linux OS are HP and Epson. To dump HP would mean spending an enormous amount of time and money on security to make up for Macrocrap's failings. I don't have Norton, McAfee, etc. I never scan attachments and surf whatever sites I feel like. If it costs me a few extra bucks for cartridges,....
 
I now understand where you're coming from. The OS dictates the hardware purchase....There's Linux drivers availble from "TurboPrint" for Canon printers. Never used them, but it's better than nothing I guess.
 
I refilled my black HP45 with some success tonight. I purchased a kit from Sam’s, Stratitec brand. It was about $18.00, so I figured if it worked out 1 time I would be half the cost of a black cartridge. I tried it first on my color cartridge. It printed OK, but I put the colors in the wrong section. Made some nice brown and gold tones after that!
grin.gif
Did not matter. I don't print pictures now, just too expensive. Today my black cartridge was out of ink. I followed the directions and they had a nifty tool that was supposed to hold a rubber boot that would hook up too the syringe allowing you to push the ink into the head. However, it would not fit. So, I went to plan B. Punched out the bottom metal ball, filled with syringe, and then put a rubber stopper in hole. It kept leaking ink out the head. Since that one device for filling did not work, I had to suck the some air out of the head with the syringe and something with a suction cup and needle. Before that, I had ink dripping all over the place. Well, it works OK, but is a little fuzzy. Not as good as new, but good enough for my needs. I made about as much mess as changing the oil on my car. If anything, the mess it makes may remind you of the good old days of 3,000 mile OCI’s.
wink.gif
 
quote:

Originally posted by labman:
I bought HP because the only choices for Linux OS are HP and Epson.

I thnk there are more. I'm getting ready to try Linux in a month or so.
Mandrake shows a boatload of printers that work with Linux.

Mandrake Hardware compatibility

This may need to be a new thread, but what distribution are you using and how did you choose it?
 
I just started to refill my ink catridges. Ink cartriges get expensive since I print a lot of stuff. My Epson C42UX does not seem to be listed on any refill kit I find. But my Canon BJC printer is listed and thats the one I refill. The instructions are not difficult to understand but you have to follow exactly as they say. It does get messy so put some newspaper on the table. And wear gloves, if the ink gets on your hands, it takes a long time to get it off. Refilling the cartrige is kind of fun. The results are very good, everything prints out nicely like I just put a new cartrige in. I recently bought another refill kit from Costco. IMS brand for about 15 dollars or something. It does list HP 56 and 57 so will work for you. www.ims-ink.com
 
I have been refilling the Canon cartridges on my venerable StarWriter word processor for years. Staples carries a good kit with a great flush to clean the head. This StarWriter model uses the obsolescent BC-01 cartridge, which is getting hard to find on the shelves; when I do find one, it is often already dried out, necessitating some work to get it going. Recently I discovered that the common BC-02 cartridge will work in this machine, but even they are often dried up out of the box. Typically I have been able to refill each cartridge at least once and usually three or four times. Much cheaper than ~$25 for a new cartridge.
 
Thanks everybody for your replies. On the issue of which printers have drivers available for Linux, I may have been the victim of bad or at least obsolete intelligence from http://www.linuxprinting.org/show_printer.cgi?recnum=HP-PSC_1110
Imagine, questioning a decision based on bad intelligence. Combining their recommendations and my bad experience with Epson, I bought HP. After finding Printdrake, I found all sorts of drivers, but not the exact one for HP psc 2175. Made do with 2170.

Demonstrating the power of Xpdf, drag to select and paste with a click. I copied a single paragraph of one column from Jelly's link.

Page for page, off-brand inks yield
little savings, despite their selling prices
What's more,we found that off-brand ink
have shortcomings that their brand-name
counterparts do not: They are likely to
yield lower-quality color photos and
graphics, and they might clog the nozzle
in the printhead.

That is something to think about. Sometimes you get what you pay for. Sometimes you can find pricing inefficiencies like Super Tech oil filters. For somebody that does a lot of printing, the good stuff would make sense, especially the way printers run out of ink just when you really need to get something printed. On the other hand, if you throw away a cartridge because it dried up before it ran out, maybe the the cheaper ones would make sense. I will mull over this some more.

''This may need to be a new thread, but what distribution are you using and how did you choose it?''

I suppose there is some command that would tell me exactly what I have now. I started with Mandrake 9.2 but upgraded to I think 9.3. I think I copied this from a start up screen some time. Release 2.4.21-013, Mandrake Konqueror 3.1.0 KDE 3.1.0
I am really struggling with Linux. Maybe I am the user the original Macintoshes were meant for. I actually got to where I knew what I was doing with my Quadra and OS 7.6.1. My son was using Mandrake 9.2. My daughter and her husband use Debian. The consensus was dad would be better off with the less geeky Mandrake. The help screens are not ready for prime time. ''To set up a printer, use Printdrake.'' Little details like the 4 steps to ge to Printdrake aren't there. The Mac help screen circled in red each place you needed to click in each step. A blond could manage a Mac. I don't think my kids own a printer, and have not been as much help as I need.

My wife does most of her work on a Power Mac, OS 7.6.1 and a Stylewriter II. I still do stuff with it to. For a sample job like a letter, no frills ClarisWorks is much faster and easier than Open Office. I was surprised how well I did with a little graphics in OO presentation. The Stylewriter is black only, uses a BC 02. If I want color, it is back to the Linux box. With an AMD AK 6 mother board, it is relatively non Wintel.
 
I've had some pretty decent luck with refilling my 57 and 56 cartridges on my HP printer.

The black one is really easy, the colors take a little more patience.

I've been using the Sam's kit someone mentioned earlier.

If you keep them topped off before they run dry, you shouldn't have a problem.
 
quote:

Originally posted by labman:
On the other hand, if you throw away a cartridge because it dried up before it ran out, maybe the the cheaper ones would make sense.

That's why I got a laser printer. I print maybe 10 pages a month, if that, and a toner cartridge will last for years. An inkjet is lucky to last a year. I don't care about color.

It's an HP LaserJet II (manufactured July 1989!)that I upgraded to a LaserJet III by changing the motherboard. I also added 4MB of RAM to it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom