Redline SI-1 vs Amsoil Pi vs Amsoil Quick Shot

Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
618
Location
USA
I'm looking for more information on these products based on my applications. So, I've been using SL-1 & P.I for typical GDI cleaning every oil change for vehicles. Now I have a new 2026 Harley Davison 117 V-Twin, lawn mower, and soon a snow blower. I've been treating the new motorcycle at the pump and small engine portable jugs with Ethanol FREE 91 fuel with SI-1 maintenance dosage. My goal is just to have a jack of all trades master of none fuel additive. Little cleaning, cylinder/fuel pump lubricant, octane improver. I'm not concerned about ethanol treatment since I run ethanol free fuel. Now it seems like Redline lists everything I need plus it's great for GDI vehicles. So being a mostly Amsoil consumer I was looking to maybe try to find the SI-1 similar equivalent like Amsoil Quick Shot, but it seems like it more geared towards fighting ethanol. Unless flagship Amsoil P.I does have upper cylinder lube which they don't list I don't believe they have something like SI-1. Should I mess with success? Regardless I have plenty SI-1 on hand and a small dwindling stash of P.I. @Pablo Any tips?
 
Sounds like Amsoil Upper Cylinder Lubricant is what you may be looking for using continuously.

Looks like their price for this UCL has gone up almost 40% in the past year. Ouch!

What part of the USA do you live? I have two cases which I doubt I'm now going to use due to a shift in what I've determined works good in my 2025 Pilot at minimizing carbon deposits. I use the Quick Shot in 90 octane, non-ethanol gasoline used in my pressure washer. Probably an overkill, but that's what I do.
 
I'm looking for more information on these products based on my applications. So, I've been using SL-1 & P.I for typical GDI cleaning every oil change for vehicles. Now I have a new 2026 Harley Davison 117 V-Twin, lawn mower, and soon a snow blower. I've been treating the new motorcycle at the pump and small engine portable jugs with Ethanol FREE 91 fuel with SI-1 maintenance dosage. My goal is just to have a jack of all trades master of none fuel additive. Little cleaning, cylinder/fuel pump lubricant, octane improver. I'm not concerned about ethanol treatment since I run ethanol free fuel. Now it seems like Redline lists everything I need plus it's great for GDI vehicles. So being a mostly Amsoil consumer I was looking to maybe try to find the SI-1 similar equivalent like Amsoil Quick Shot, but it seems like it more geared towards fighting ethanol. Unless flagship Amsoil P.I does have upper cylinder lube which they don't list I don't believe they have something like SI-1. Should I mess with success? Regardless I have plenty SI-1 on hand and a small dwindling stash of P.I. @Pablo Any tips?
Thing is, nothing you put in your fuel will really clean up a true GDI mess on the intake side.

No small bottle from anyone will improve AKI significantly.

Do fuel pumps need extra lube? I actually wonder about that.

I would stick with a good injector cleaner.
 
Thing is, nothing you put in your fuel will really clean up a true GDI mess on the intake side.

No small bottle from anyone will improve AKI significantly.

Do fuel pumps need extra lube? I actually wonder about that.

I would stick with a good injector cleaner.
What about combustion chamber cleanliness?
 
Back
Top Bottom