So many variables that performance is simply never guaranteed in my experience. Ambient temp, cold soak time, displacement, condition of terminals, quality of clamps (most suck), side or top terminal, COO and age of pack are just a few.
Even if Audew or GooLoo is presently the PF darling, after a few years it's anyone's guess if it'll work. They can show 100% and then the second you try to use it they show 0%. Then recover to 90%.
Couple this with a shifting market or changes in manufacturers and the Amazing GooLoo of 2023 might be significantly cheapened in 2025.
- Yes, it is true a well-tested pack gives you better odds of success.
- Yes, it is true someone will.say they used a 15-yr old Audew that was never charged to start a completely dead 5.9 CTD. The sun shines on a dog's posterior every once in a great while.
- Yes I carry li-ion packs as a first line of defense but I know there's never a guarantee, unlike quality jumper cables which are virtually guaranteed with proper technique, or a good JNC as second place.
If you read the Amazon reviews, even the "good" packs have high failure rates. What sets them apart is some manufacturers replace them with little hassle (also laid out in Amazon reviews).