Originally Posted by Garak
Originally Posted by Eddddd
Garak, Obviously you know nothing about the VQ37 and the issues it had with oil overheating forcing it to go into limp mode. Conventional oil?! That engine will sludge up with conventional oil as hard as it is on oil. Also, LSPI is a non issue on. the VQ37. It's irrelevant.
No, I know nothing about them whatsoever.
The engine limp mode, which does exist, does not happen at a temperature that significantly stresses the ability of a conventional oil to do its job over the very short OEM OCIs. The limp mode happens during hard driving and not during normal driving. I've personally never come across it once during 150,000 km of usage even while using a 40 grade or a 3.5 HTHS 5w30. Nonetheless, if someone is engaged in driving practices that regularly, or even occasionally, bring them into limp mode, it's time to upgrade the engine oil cooling, which is a fairly straightforward modification. You're forgetting a very important point about basic physics. An oil like Red Line 5w30 will get hotter than an ILSAC 5w30, therefore more readily bringing the VQ37 to limp mode. If one is experiencing limp mode, the answer to that isn't a thicker oil. The answer is to improve engine cooling first. I'm also aware the LSPI is not an issue with these engines. Burla and I were discussing another matter, only tangentially related because of Red Line being brought up. Note I was mentioning Ford. You're lucky I read this before burla did, or he would have given you what for over it.
As bbhero points out, the vehicle calls for the current API spec or newer 5w30 with ILSAC being optional. A properly changed conventional over OEM severe service intervals isn't a concern. Where I do have concerns with Infiniti is when that engine was deprecated and OCIs went to 10,000 miles with conventional being permissible. 3750 miles on PYB is a breeze on a 3.7 under normal driving conditions. On the turbo replacement, 10,000 miles on PYB might be questionable.
I'm the first one to try a thicker oil (like Rotella T6 Multi-Vehicle 5w30) or experiment out of spec where reasonable to do so. However, "VQ37" isn't a justification for a $100 DIY oil change. I have no problem with Motul or Red Line where someone can actually gain something from their use. This scenario isn't one of them, and I can list about two dozen oils right off the top of my head to use ahead of them in a 3.7. I can still keep the number quite high while disqualifying all ILSAC oils. His idea to use M1 0w-40 will work splendidly at one third the cost of a Red Line or Motul. The same goes for any other mainstream A3/B4, C3, E6 and/or E7, E9 type lube.
I have to agree on the Rotella MV, I just posted a UOA on my last OCI and it bested QSUD, PP and Mobil Super by a mile. My engine is particularly hard on oil and it's the only oil so far that did not shear in a 20 grade.
I got it from napa at 50$ plus tax for a 5 litres jug and also there is a 7$ MIR at the moment in Canada.
It is also SN PLUS!