A lot of the rust "Converter" products are latex based,and do little.They change color to a dark tint to show they "work",but rust is soon to reappear.Blast the area,and repaint from scratch (primer,paint,clear). [/quote}
Well I have some experience with rust converters mainly Corroseal. Happens to be used by MARAD on the ships in the reserve fleet which get very rusty. Saw them using it when on some of the ships and decided to try it on the ship I restore. Needless to say it is a tough environment with wind, sun, fog, salt air and standing water.
I go over a deck with hammer and chisel before a wire wheel on Makita rotary. Then cover with Corroseal, let cure, next a moisture cured urethane tie coat followed by a catalyzed polyurethane deck gray. Some areas are now going on 3 years, and if I didn't miss a microscopic spot then nothing has come back. Used it a year ago on the steel engine mount of a Wildcat, pulled out of the Great Lakes, after the best cleaning we could do. Covered with two coats epoxy and I just looked today. Still spotless.
My take on POR-15 is that on my ship it is worthless. Couldn't handle standing water for even one rainy season before rust was back.