Sulphur, and heavy metals
Tires already are, Understand there supposedly are massive numbers of used tires consumed by industry everyday and that’s we’re the so called recycled tires go, asphalt, playground and ground cover, cement makers (oddly) and a variety of other industrial uses.
Why they aren’t used for consumer gasoline…
while “most” plastics have minimal sulphur and will pyrolyse cleanly in an air free environment around 500 degrees with minimal gas output and lighter hydrocarbons ,
tires don’t completely give up the ghost until 1000 with partial decomposition starting around 700ish.
Once you do because tires are much more complex you get lots of nasty chemistry experiments going on during pryolisis which damage the oil/heavy diesel you get out of the process (more chaostic, acidic and sulphur filled) and tires make a lot more very noxious gas output that stinks up the neighborhood than most normal plastics which are nearly single chemical items.
This isn’t to say a big calcium pile and water bubbler couldn’t greatly reduce the most obvious stench but the extra heat energy, chemical additives and complexity makes it more expensive to clean up the hydrocarbons you get out as compared to acid free sulphur free plastic outputs